SIS Proof Test Deferral Risk Index (SPTDRI)

GMI-PI-013Process IndustriesIntegration-RequiredPattern R-4: Margin Consumption

Definition

Ratio of the estimated probability of failure on demand under the actual proof test intervals being practiced (including AI-recommended extensions) to the PFD target for the SIF's assigned Safety Integrity Level: detecting whether AI proof test optimization is maintaining the SIL or consuming the safety margin defined by the LOPA analysis.

The Measurement Gap

AI-based proof test optimization is a vendor pitch with strong economics: extend intervals where component health data supports it, reduce test burden, free up maintenance hours. The economics are real. What the alarm management metrics, SIS adherence reports, and PFD calculations as published do not surface is whether the cumulative effect of the AI's interval extensions has pushed the PFD beyond the SIL target. Proof test adherence rate measures whether tests happened on the AI-recommended schedule; it goes up as the AI extends intervals. Mean time between proof tests is gameable for the same reason. PFD calculation appears in the SIL verification document, but the document is built on assumed intervals: it is not continuously recomputed against actual intervals. The failure mode is regulatory: when an AI-extended interval pushes PFD above the SIL boundary, the SIF no longer meets the integrity level the LOPA assigned, and the LOPA itself becomes invalid. None of the day-to-day metrics surfaces this.

Decision Supported:

Is the AI's recommendation to extend proof test intervals maintaining the SIF within its required SIL, or has the cumulative interval extension increased PFD beyond the level the LOPA analysis assumed?

Formula

Plain language: Recompute the PFD using the proof test intervals actually being practiced (after AI extensions), then divide by the PFD target for the SIL the SIF was assigned. Below 1.0 means the SIF still meets its SIL. Above 1.0 means the SIF does not.

Notation:

SPTDRI = PFD_estimated_current / PFD_target_SIL

Variables:

Variable Definition Unit
PFD_estimated_current Estimated PFD under actual practiced intervals (including AI extensions), calculated using IEC 61511 simplified equations or vendor PFD curves dimensionless (probability)
PFD_target_SIL PFD target for the SIF's assigned SIL (SIL 1: 1e-1 to 1e-2; SIL 2: 1e-2 to 1e-3; SIL 3: 1e-3 to 1e-4) dimensionless (probability)
λ_DU Dangerous undetected failure rate from the SIL verification calculation failures per hour
Computed per Individual SIF, not aggregated across SIFs n/a

Track SPTDRI per SIF, with attention to the rate of change after AI extension events.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Ratio
Trend Direction
Lower; approaching 1.0 is a regulatory warning
Reporting Frequency
Per SIF, reviewed monthly with formal review at 0.80 and above
Category
Safety, Environmental and Regulatory Margin Governance
← Permit Margin Consumption Index (PMCI)Transient Emissions Accuracy Gap (TEAG) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment