Multi-Objective Tradeoff Drift Index (MOTDI)

GMI-PI-002Process IndustriesIntegration-RequiredPattern O-6: Autonomous Coherence

Definition

Cumulative drift in the RTO's effective allocation of optimization value across competing objectives (yield, energy, quality, and throughput) measured against the approved optimization philosophy, to detect whether the optimizer has silently shifted the tradeoff balance away from the priorities the process engineering team approved.

The Measurement Gap

The new decision is whether the optimizer's behavior over time still represents what was sanctioned when the RTO went live. The failure mode is silent reweighting: each individual move stays within process constraints, but the aggregate effect over months is that one objective gains and others lose. Energy intensity is the most common loser because energy degradation is slow and stays within variance bands. Yield reports show the wins; energy and quality reports show drift that gets attributed to feedstock or seasonal effects. Throughput, conversion, yield, and unit energy intensity each measure one objective: none measures the optimizer's effective allocation across all four. The RTO's published objective function is the design intent, not the realized behavior. Without a continuous measurement of effective tradeoff allocation against approved allocation, the optimizer is governed by who notices the secondary objective slipping first.

Decision Supported:

Has the RTO's effective weighting of yield versus energy versus quality versus throughput drifted from the weights the process engineering team approved, and if so, in which direction and by how much?

Formula

Plain language: For each objective, compare what the optimizer is effectively prioritizing right now to what was approved when the RTO went live. Sum the absolute differences across objectives and divide by the number of objectives, that average deviation is the drift index.

Notation:

MOTDI = ( Σ | w_effective_i(t) − w_approved_i | ) / N_objectives

Variables:

Variable Definition Unit
w_effective_i(t) Effective weight the RTO is placing on objective i, derived from actual marginal improvement in i relative to marginal degradation in other objectives over rolling 30-day windows dimensionless weight (0–1)
w_approved_i Approved weight for objective i as documented in the RTO configuration or the process engineering optimization philosophy dimensionless weight (0–1)
N_objectives Number of objectives the RTO is configured to balance count
i Index of objective (yield, energy, quality, throughput, etc.) n/a

Reported alongside MOTDI: per-objective direction (which objectives gained weight, which lost). The aggregate index without the direction breakdown is half a measurement.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Index
Trend Direction
Lower; Decreasing toward zero
Reporting Frequency
Rolling 30-day windows, reviewed quarterly
Category
AI Process Optimization Integrity
← Constraint Boundary Time-at-Risk (CBTR)Precursor Signal Suppression Rate (PSSR) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment