Definition
S3MLI measures the value-chain emissions generated by maintenance logistics (parts transport, technician travel, and supplier processing) relative to the production loss avoided by the intervention.
The Measurement Gap
Maintenance logistics emissions sit in Scope 3. Category 4 (Upstream Transportation and Distribution) and Category 1 (Purchased Goods and Services) under the GHG Protocol. Most organizations report Scope 3 only at the enterprise level, twelve months after the fact, with no connection to the maintenance decisions that caused the emissions. MTBF counts failures, MTTR counts hours, OEE counts output, PM Compliance counts schedule adherence: none differentiate a part that was sitting in the storeroom from an identical part flown in from another continent on an emergency charter. The freight premium shows up in actual costs; the carbon cost is invisible until annual aggregation. A single emergency airfreight shipment can generate more CO2e than the entire plant's electrical load consumes in a week.
Decision Supported:
Sourcing and timing decisions for parts replenishment, including the carbon trade-off between local stocking versus emergency international airfreight.
Formula
Plain language: For each work order (or rolling period), sum the Scope 3 emissions from parts transport, technician travel, and supplier processing. Divide by the avoided unplanned loss value of that work order. Lower is better.
Notation:
S3MLI = CO2e_logistics(W) / $AvoidedUnplannedLoss(W)
Component decomposition:
CO2e_logistics(W) = Sigma(shipment_weight x distance x freight_mode_factor) + Sigma(technician_travel_distance x travel_mode_factor) + Sigma(supplier_processing_factor)
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| CO2e_logistics(W) | Total Scope 3 emissions from logistics for work order W | kg CO2e |
| $AvoidedUnplannedLoss(W) | Estimated cost of unplanned downtime that would have occurred without the intervention | $ |
| Freight mode factor | DEFRA / EPA emissions factor by mode (air, ground, ocean) | kg CO2e / tonne-km |
| Technician travel factor | Aviation, road, or rail emissions factor | kg CO2e / passenger-km |
| Shipment weight | Mass of parts shipped per work order | tonnes |
| Distance | Vendor-to-plant distance | km |
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.