Definition
CMI measures how circular maintenance material flows actually are, on a scale from 0 (linear: virgin in, waste out) to 1 (fully circular: all materials reused, remanufactured, or recycled), combining four weighted components.
The Measurement Gap
No legacy maintenance KPI measures material flow direction. MTBF tells you time between failures with no visibility into whether replacement parts were virgin steel or remanufactured components. Total maintenance cost captures spend but does not distinguish virgin from remanufactured. If anything, legacy cost metrics penalize circularity because remanufactured parts often look cheaper but the savings vanish in budget variance noise. PM Compliance scores a 98% PM rate achieved entirely with virgin materials identically to one achieved with 40% remanufactured content. OEE has zero visibility into the supply chain behind the parts. Sustainability reports cite "circular economy commitments" while storeroom material flow stays straight-line, and no metric on the maintenance dashboard measures the gap.
Decision Supported:
Procurement policy for remanufactured parts, disposition routing for removed components, and circular-economy reporting at fleet level.
Formula
Plain language: Combine four weighted components (material circularity of parts consumed, refurbishment rate of parts removed, inverted virgin-spend fraction, and inverted fugitive leak rate) into a single composite index.
Notation:
CMI = w1 x MCI_parts + w2 x RR + w3 x (1 - VirginSpend / TotalSpend) + w4 x (1 - LeakRate / Benchmark)
MCI_parts = 1 - LFI x F(X), where LFI = (V + W) / (2 x M)
Suggested weights: w1 = 0.25, w2 = 0.30, w3 = 0.30, w4 = 0.15, summing to 1.
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| MCI_parts | Ellen MacArthur Material Circularity Indicator applied to consumed parts | 0–1 |
| RR | Refurbishment Rate: mass refurbished / total mass removed | 0–1 |
| VirginSpend / TotalSpend | Fraction of parts spend on virgin (vs. remanufactured) | 0–1 |
| LeakRate | Measured fugitive emission rate for controlled substances | % |
| Benchmark | Reference leak rate (e.g., EPA 608 = 10%) | % |
| V, W, M | Virgin input mass, unrecoverable waste mass, total product mass | kg |
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.