Definition
PSWAI measures the change in water age at the worst-case storage location resulting from AI-optimized pump scheduling.
The Measurement Gap
The Measurement Gap
What Legacy Metrics See:
Traditional distribution system monitoring tracks chlorine residuals at system extremities, disinfection byproduct (DBP) levels at compliance sampling points, storage tank turnover rates, and customer complaint frequency for taste and odor. Pump scheduling metrics track energy consumption, pump runtime, and cost per million gallons delivered. These two metric families operate independently.
What Legacy Metrics Miss:
No standard metric connects pump schedule changes to water age changes at specific system locations. A utility that shifts 40% of its pumping to off-peak hours may be extending water age by 18 hours at its worst-case storage tank: pushing that tank from borderline-compliant DBP levels to exceedance risk. The chlorine residual monitoring might catch the consequence eventually, but by then the water age increase has been compounding for months. The causal link (pump schedule optimization causing water age increase causing chlorine decay causing DBP formation) crosses three operational domains that typically don't share metrics.
The Decision This KPI Enables:
PSWAI enables the utility to set explicit water age constraints on the pump scheduling optimizer before water quality consequences materialize. When PSWAI exceeds 25% at any storage location, the utility can constrain pump scheduling at that specific location, increase tank turnover through operational rules, add booster chlorination, or accept the trade-off with full visibility of the water quality risk. Without PSWAI, the pump scheduler optimizes energy cost while water quality staff chase chlorine residual complaints they can't trace to a root cause.
Relevant Research:
AWWA research on distribution system water quality establishes clear relationships between water age and disinfection byproduct formation, with total trihalomethane (TTHM) and haloacetic acid (HAA5) concentrations increasing with residence time. EPA studies on storage tank management document water age as a primary driver of water quality degradation in distribution systems, with dead zones and low-turnover tanks identified as the highest-risk locations.
Formula
Plain language: Using the hydraulic model or tracer study data, estimate water age (residence time from treatment plant to storage facility and from storage facility to customer) under the AI-optimized pump schedule. Compare to the same estimate under the pre-optimization schedule. The difference is the AI's water age contribution.
Notation:
PSWAI = (WA_optimized - WA_baseline) / WA_baseline
Where:
- WA_optimized = estimated water age at the worst-case storage facility under AI-optimized pump schedule (hours)
- WA_baseline = estimated water age at the same facility under pre-optimization schedule (hours)
- "Worst-case" = the facility with the highest water age
Units: Percentage change. Positive = increased water age (bad: more time for chlorine decay, DBP formation, lead corrosion product dissolution). Negative = decreased water age (good: the optimization actually improved turnover).
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.