Definition
DRTI measures treatment process degradation that occurs within 72 hours of AI-driven energy curtailment for grid demand response participation.
The Measurement Gap
The Measurement Gap
What Legacy Metrics See:
Traditional demand response metrics track energy curtailment volume (kW reduced), response time to grid signals, revenue earned from demand response programs, and compliance with curtailment commitments. Treatment metrics track effluent quality, process stability, and permit compliance on their own independent timelines. These two metric sets exist in separate departments with separate reporting structures.
What Legacy Metrics Miss:
No standard metric connects demand response events to subsequent treatment quality. A utility earning $180K annually from demand response participation may be experiencing systematic treatment degradation that increases chemical costs, extends recovery times, and occasionally pushes effluent parameters toward permit limits. Because treatment metrics are reviewed on daily or weekly averages and demand response events last 2–4 hours, the degradation signal is diluted below visibility in standard reporting. The cause-and-effect relationship (curtailment at 2 PM causing elevated turbidity at 6 PM and incomplete nitrification at 10 PM) spans shift changes and crosses departmental boundaries.
The Decision This KPI Enables:
DRTI gives the utility director a clear trade-off: demand response revenue versus treatment stability cost. When DRTI exceeds 10%, the director can decide to limit curtailment to processes with minimal treatment impact, shorten curtailment duration, invest in process resilience that tolerates curtailment, or exit demand response programs that create unacceptable treatment risk. Without DRTI, the utility books demand response revenue as pure profit while treatment staff absorb the consequences without a common metric to quantify the connection.
Relevant Research:
Published studies on demand response in water/wastewater utilities document energy savings and revenue opportunities but rarely quantify treatment process impacts from curtailment events. Biological treatment process dynamics research shows that aeration interruptions as short as 30 minutes can cause measurable nitrification disruption in activated sludge systems, with recovery times extending 4–12 hours depending on system loading and temperature.
Formula
Plain language: For each demand response curtailment event, compare treatment process performance (effluent quality, DO profile, ammonia trend, process stability indicators) in the 72 hours after curtailment to the 72 hours before. Score the degradation.
Notation:
DRTI = Sum(WQ_degradation_i x w_p) / N_DR_events
Where:
- WQ_degradation_i = maximum deviation of parameter p from baseline in the 72 hours following DR event i, expressed as percentage of baseline
- w_p = parameter weight (permit-limited parameters: w=3.0; process indicators like DO, SVI: w=2.0; aesthetic: w=1.0)
- N_DR_events = number of demand response events in the measurement period
Units: Weighted percentage degradation per event. 0 = no treatment impact. Positive = degradation. Track alongside demand response revenue to enable cost-benefit analysis.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.