Definition
Difference between the fuel budget assigned to a train (based on fleet-average consist assumptions) and the fuel budget a consist-adjusted model would assign given the actual train's tonnage, length, aerodynamic profile, and route characteristics.
The Measurement Gap
The Measurement Gap
Railroads assign fuel targets to trains based on fleet-average assumptions: standard consist weight, standard aerodynamic profile, standard route characteristics. In practice, consists vary enormously. A 150-car loaded coal train and a 90-car mixed manifest have fundamentally different fuel consumption profiles, but they may receive targets from the same fleet-average model. Engineers running heavy or aerodynamically unfavorable consists are penalized for missing targets that were never achievable.
This gap matters because unfair fuel targets create perverse incentives. Engineers who consistently miss unachievable targets may override the energy management system (showing up in EOOVI), slow down to meet targets at the expense of schedule (showing up in ESNVI), or simply disengage from fuel management as a performance metric because they've learned it's rigged against certain consists.
Decision Supported:
Are fuel targets fair to train crews given their actual consist, or is the fleet-average assumption forcing schedule compromises on non-average trains? Should fuel targets be consist-specific? CAFTV provides the fairness data to migrate from fleet-average to consist-adjusted targeting.
Formula
Plain Language: For each train, compute what the fuel target should have been given the actual consist (tonnage, car count, aerodynamic drag coefficient, loaded/empty mix). Compare to the fuel target the system assigned using fleet-average assumptions. The variance shows whether the crew is being judged against an achievable or unrealistic target.
Notation:
CAFTV = (Fuel_target_assigned − Fuel_target_consist_adjusted) / Fuel_target_consist_adjusted
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit | Source | Classification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fuel_target_assigned | Fuel budget assigned to the train by the standard model | Gallons | Fuel management system | NATIVE |
| Fuel_target_consist_adjusted | Fuel budget computed from the actual consist's tonnage, length, car type mix, and aerodynamic profile | Gallons | Train dynamics model | DERIVED |
Sign Convention: 0% = target is fair. Positive = target is too tight (crew is penalized for a hard consist). Negative = target is too generous (crew gets unearned credit for an easy consist).
Edge Cases:
- Mixed consist with cars added/removed en route: compute CAFTV for each segment between set-out/pick-up events, not for the full trip.
- Consist data unavailable at departure: if actual consist characteristics aren't known until after departure (dynamic blocking), CAFTV becomes a retrospective fairness metric rather than a pre-trip adjustment.
- Minimum sample: 100 trains per measurement period.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.