Definition
Percentage of regenerative braking energy that was actually consumed by another train in the same electrical section at the time of regeneration, versus energy that was dissipated in braking resistors because no coincident load existed.
The Measurement Gap
The Measurement Gap
Electrified railroads report regenerative braking energy as a fuel savings number: kilowatt-hours returned to the catenary. What they don't report is whether that energy was actually used. When a train regenerates energy into the catenary, it only has economic value if another train in the same electrical section is simultaneously drawing traction power. If no train is drawing, the regenerated energy is dissipated as heat in braking resistors: the regeneration happened mechanically, but economically it was zero.
This gap matters because regeneration statistics can significantly overstate actual energy savings. A railroad reporting 15% energy recovery through regeneration may actually be realizing 5% if only a third of regeneration events coincide with traction demand. The rest is accounting fiction that flatters the efficiency numbers.
Decision Supported:
Is the regenerated energy the railroad reports actually delivering economic value, or is it a mechanical event with no economic effect? Should braking profiles be coordinated with traction demand in the electrical section? REY provides the economic-reality check on regeneration statistics.
Formula
Plain Language: When a train regenerates energy into the catenary, check whether another train in the same electrical section was simultaneously drawing traction power. If yes, the regenerated energy offset purchased energy. If no, the regenerated energy was dissipated as heat: mechanically real, economically zero.
Notation:
REY = Energy_consumed_by_others / Energy_regenerated_total
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit | Source | Classification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Energy_consumed_by_others | Regenerated energy absorbed by coincident traction load in the electrical section | kWh | Traction power monitoring | INTEGRATION |
| Energy_regenerated_total | Total energy returned to the catenary by regenerative braking | kWh | Locomotive energy metering | NATIVE |
Sign Convention: 1.0 = all regeneration had economic value. 0.0 = all regeneration was wasted. Track by electrical section and time of day.
Edge Cases:
- Grid-connected catenary: excess regeneration can sometimes be fed back to the utility grid. Track three categories: consumed by train (full value), fed to grid (partial value at feed-in tariff rate), dissipated (zero value).
- Non-electrified territory: REY is undefined. Diesel-electric regeneration always dissipates in resistors unless the locomotive has battery-hybrid energy storage. Exclude diesel territory.
- Minimum sample: 200 regeneration events per electrical section per measurement period.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.