Definition
Ratio of aging degradation mechanisms covered by the current AI-optimized inspection scope to the mechanisms covered by the original (pre-optimization or regulatory commitment) inspection program, measured per aging management program element.
The Measurement Gap
Aging management programs in nuclear plants define inspection scopes based on the degradation mechanisms applicable to each component material-environment combination. When AI optimization recommends reducing the inspection scope (fewer examination locations, longer intervals, fewer mechanism-specific inspections), the reduction may be technically justified or it may introduce survivor bias. No legacy metric tracks the cumulative scope reduction across program review cycles. Aging management program health indicators track inspection completion rates and finding trends. GALL/GALL-SLR comparison metrics track program alignment with regulatory guidance. Neither measures whether the AI optimization is systematically reducing coverage of degradation mechanisms across successive review cycles, creating a compounding gap between what the program was designed to detect and what it actually examines. The invisible failure mode is that scope reduction compounds across review cycles: the AI removes mechanisms with no findings, which means fewer findings in the next cycle, which justifies further scope reduction, creating a positive feedback loop that erodes coverage while each individual reduction appears justified.
Decision Supported
Is the AI-optimized aging management program maintaining coverage of all degradation mechanisms the original program was designed to detect, or is scope reduction introducing survivor bias?
Formula
Plain language: For each aging management program element (each component group, each material-environment combination, each degradation mechanism per GALL/NUREG-1801), compare the current AI-optimized inspection scope against the original program scope (the scope at license renewal commitment or initial program establishment). Count the mechanisms that are still covered and the mechanisms that have been removed from the inspection scope.
Notation:
AISCF_e = DM_current_scope_e / DM_original_scope_e
Program composite:
AISCF = Σ_e (w_e × AISCF_e) / Σ_e w_e
Variables:
- DM_current_scope_e = degradation mechanisms actively inspected under the current AI-optimized scope for program element e (count)
- DM_original_scope_e = degradation mechanisms inspected under the original/commitment scope for program element e (count)
- w_e = safety significance weight of program element e (based on component safety classification and material-environment severity)
- e = each aging management program element
Sign convention: AISCF = 1.0 means full original scope maintained. Below 1.0 means scope has been reduced. Lower is worse.
Aggregation period: Per aging management program review cycle (typically 5-10 years for license renewal commitment reviews, annually for program health assessments).
Edge Cases
- New degradation mechanisms added to the program (from industry OE, new research): these expand the original scope denominator. If the AI optimization reduced other mechanisms while new ones were added, AISCF may remain stable while the composition of coverage shifts: track mechanism-level additions and removals separately
- Mechanisms removed because the material or environment has been changed (replaced component, chemistry regime change): legitimate scope reduction. Exclude from AISCF if the removal basis is documented and technically justified
- Original program scope was overly conservative (inspecting mechanisms that don't apply to the actual material-environment combination): AISCF below 1.0 may be technically justified. Require engineering documentation for each mechanism removed from scope.
- Programs with very few mechanisms (< 3): AISCF becomes granular (any single removal is a large percentage change). Flag for engineering review regardless of the percentage
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.