PMT Scope Adequacy Factor (PMTSAF)

GMI-NUC-021Nuclear OperationsIntegration-Required

Definition

Ratio of safety functions verified by the AI-recommended PMT scope to safety functions that could have been affected by the maintenance activity, measuring whether the reduced PMT scope still covers the full functional verification requirement.

The Measurement Gap

Post-maintenance testing (PMT) is the final verification that a maintained safety component's functions have been restored. When AI systems recommend reduced PMT scope (fewer tests, narrower test conditions, streamlined procedures), the plant saves time and resources. But no metric measures whether the reduced scope still covers all the safety functions that could have been affected by the maintenance activity. Maintenance Rule functional failure tracking captures failures that occur in service. PMT completion rate tracks whether testing was performed. Neither measures whether the testing scope was adequate to detect a latent deficiency before the component returns to service. The invisible failure mode is that AI-recommended PMT scope reduction removes tests that cover functions genuinely affected by the maintenance activity, and the latent deficiency survives into operation because the PMT that would have caught it was optimized away.

Decision Supported

Does the AI-recommended PMT scope adequately verify that the maintained component's safety functions were restored, or has the scope reduction removed tests that cover functions actually affected by the maintenance activity?

Formula

Plain language: For each maintenance activity, identify all safety functions the maintained component supports (from the safety function list / Maintenance Rule functional failure definitions). Determine which of those functions the AI-recommended PMT scope verifies. Divide verified by total affected. Compare to the PMT scope that was historically used for the same or similar maintenance activities.

Notation:
PMTSAF = SF_verified / SF_affected

Historical comparison:
PMTSAF_delta = PMTSAF_current - PMTSAF_baseline

Variables:

  • SF_verified = number of safety functions with at least one test in the AI-recommended PMT scope that exercises that function (count)
  • SF_affected = number of safety functions that could have been affected by the maintenance activity, based on the component's safety function list and the maintenance scope (count)
  • SF identification follows NUMARC 93-01 Section 11 guidance on PMT scope determination
  • PMTSAF_baseline = historical PMTSAF for the same maintenance activity type (before AI-recommended scope changes)

Sign convention: PMTSAF = 1.0 means every affected safety function has test coverage. Lower is worse. PMTSAF_delta negative means the AI has reduced coverage relative to historical practice.

Aggregation period: Per maintenance activity (each PMT scope decision is evaluated), rolled up monthly.

Edge Cases

  • Safety function is verified by an existing surveillance that runs independently of the PMT: count as "verified by other means". The function has coverage even if the PMT scope doesn't include it. Track separately from "verified by PMT" so the distinction is visible.
  • Maintenance activity scope was minor (gasket replacement, lubricant change) and no safety functions were actually affected: PMTSAF is 1.0 by definition. The numerator and denominator are both zero or both the same. Include in denominator as "trivially adequate" but don't weight in trend analysis.
  • AI recommends expanded PMT scope (more testing than historical): PMTSAF > 1.0 is possible if the AI identifies affected functions the historical scope missed. This is a positive finding: capture it.
  • Minimum: all maintenance activities on safety-related and MR (a)(1) components (census, not sampled)

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Ratio
Trend Direction
Toward 1.0
Reporting Frequency
Monthly
Category
Maintenance Program Rigor Erosion
← Degradation Mechanism Monitoring Coverage Ratio (DMMCR)ALARA Dose Equity Index (ADEI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment