Cumulative Risk Deferral Burden (CRDB)

GMI-NUC-010Nuclear OperationsIntegration-Required

Definition

Aggregate change in core damage frequency (delta-CDF) attributable to the cumulative set of concurrently active risk-informed maintenance and surveillance deferrals, compared to the as-designed maintenance program baseline.

The Measurement Gap

Risk-informed maintenance and surveillance deferrals are individually evaluated against Maintenance Rule (a)(4) risk thresholds, and each individual deferral may be justified. But the cumulative effect of many concurrent deferrals is not tracked by any existing metric. Maintenance Rule (a)(2) criteria track system-level performance but not the aggregate risk contribution of all active deferrals. Scram rate and capacity factor measure plant operational outcomes. Schedule compliance tracks whether planned work gets done. The PRA model computes instantaneous risk for specific configurations but does not track the accumulated delta-CDF from the full portfolio of active deferrals against the plant's risk allocation budget. The invisible failure mode is that each individual deferral passes the (a)(4) risk screen, but the collection of concurrent deferrals approaches or exceeds the total risk allocation that no individual decision violated. The risk budget erodes one approved deferral at a time.

Decision Supported

Have the individually acceptable risk-informed deferrals accumulated into a total risk burden that exceeds thresholds no individual decision violated?

Formula

Plain language: For every currently active deferral (maintenance deferred, surveillance interval extended, degraded condition accepted based on risk-informed evaluation), compute the incremental risk contribution (delta-CDF) of that deferral. Sum them. Compare the sum to the total risk budget the plant has allocated for risk-informed activities.

Notation:
CRDB = Σ_j ΔCDF_j / ΔCDF_budget

Variables:

  • ΔCDF_j = incremental change in core damage frequency attributable to deferral j, computed from the PRA model with the deferred component in its current (degraded or uninspected) state vs. its as-maintained state (per reactor-year, typically expressed as 1E-7/yr increments)
  • ΔCDF_budget = the plant's total risk-informed activity risk allocation, typically derived from the Maintenance Rule (a)(4) risk management guidelines and the plant's integrated risk-informed decision-making (IRIDM) threshold (per reactor-year)
  • j = each currently active risk-informed deferral (count)

Sign convention: CRDB < 1.0 means the cumulative deferral burden is within the risk budget. CRDB ≥ 1.0 means the portfolio has consumed the full risk allocation. CRDB > 1.0 is a hard threshold violation. Lower is better.

Aggregation period: Real-time snapshot (CRDB should be recalculated whenever a new deferral is added or an existing deferral is retired).

Edge Cases

  • Correlated deferrals (two deferred components in the same system): the combined delta-CDF may be greater than the sum of individual contributions due to common-cause or system-level effects. Use the PRA's full model solution, not the sum of individual component deltas, when deferrals overlap on the same safety function
  • PRA model resolution limits: if the PRA doesn't model a deferred component explicitly, use a bounding estimate. Do not assume delta-CDF = 0 for unmodeled components
  • CRDB can only be computed if the PRA model is current: CRDB × PRICI gives a confidence-adjusted risk burden. If PRICI is low, CRDB is unreliable even if the number looks acceptable.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Rate
Trend Direction
Higher
Reporting Frequency
Monthly
Category
Risk and Margin Accumulation
← Conservative Decision Drift Index (CDDI)Outage Access Window Consumption Index (OAWCI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment