Promotional Timing Circularity Score (PTCS)

GMI-MKT-PPO-010Marketing: Pricing and Promotional OptimizationIntegration-Required

Definition

The degree to which AI-optimized promotional timing concentrates demand into promotional windows by schedule predictability rather than capturing natural demand peaks, measuring whether the promotional AI is finding demand or manufacturing it through self-fulfilling scheduling patterns.

The Measurement Gap

The Gap

Promotional AI learns when demand peaks occur and schedules promotions to coincide with them. Quarter after quarter, the AI gets better at timing. Promotional windows show higher and higher concentration of demand. The promotional team reports improving optimization. But there is a circularity problem that no legacy metric detects.

When promotions consistently run at the same time, customers learn the schedule. They defer purchases to the expected promotional window. Demand that would have occurred naturally across the period concentrates into the promotional windows -- not because the AI found the natural peak, but because the AI created the peak through scheduling predictability. The promotional AI then observes this concentrated demand and concludes that its timing is excellent, reinforcing the same schedule. The prediction creates the reality it predicted.

Promotional lift metrics measure the demand concentration during promotional windows and report it as success. Conversion rate during promotional periods improves, which the AI interprets as evidence of good timing. Revenue concentration analysis shows demand peaking during promotions, which looks like evidence that promotions are aligned with natural demand. No standard metric tests whether the demand pattern would exist without the promotional schedule -- because testing that requires the organizational willingness to randomize promotional timing.

The Decision

We propose PTCS to answer: Are we timing promotions to capture natural demand peaks, or have we trained customers to buy only when they know the promotion is coming? This metric would compare demand concentration under AI-optimized scheduling to demand concentration under randomized scheduling at the same frequency, isolating the self-created component of demand concentration.

Formula

Plain Language

Run promotions at the AI-optimized times for one group. For a test group, run the same number of promotions at random times. Measure how concentrated demand is in each group -- specifically, the ratio of revenue during promotional windows to revenue during non-promotional windows. If the AI-scheduled group shows much higher concentration than the random group, the difference is demand that was created by scheduling predictability rather than captured from natural peaks. PTCS normalizes this as a 0-to-1 score where 0 means the AI is purely capturing natural patterns and 1.0 means it has entirely manufactured the demand pattern.

Notation

PTCS = 1 - (Concentration_random / Concentration_AI)

Where:

Concentration = Revenue_promo_windows / Revenue_non_promo_windows

Variables

Variable Definition Units Source System
Concentration_AI Ratio of revenue during promotional windows to revenue during non-promotional windows under the AI-optimized schedule Ratio E-commerce / Billing (Derived)
Concentration_random Ratio of revenue during promotional windows to revenue during non-promotional windows under same-frequency randomized scheduling Ratio Experimentation Platform (Derived)

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Index (0 to 1)
Trend Direction
Lower
Reporting Frequency
Quarterly
Category
Pricing Power and Brand Positioning
← Pricing Power Trend Index (PPTI)Discount Contamination Index (DCTI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment