Definition
The net revenue and margin impact of a promotion measured across the full demand displacement window, including the promotional spike, the post-promotional valley, and the total discount cost, expressed as a percentage of what margin would have been without the promotion.
The Measurement Gap
The Gap
Promotional Incrementality Rate tells you what percentage of lift is genuine. But even genuine incrementality can destroy value if the discount cost exceeds the incremental margin. A promotion with 70% incrementality sounds excellent -- until you calculate that the discount given on all units (incremental and non-incremental alike) exceeded the margin earned on the genuinely new sales.
Promotional lift measures volume impact but is silent on margin impact. Promotional ROI as typically calculated divides promotional revenue by promotional cost, but "promotional cost" rarely includes the full cost: the discount on units that would have sold at full price, the margin compression on incremental units, and the revenue valley in the post-promotional period. Gross margin during the promotional period captures the margin rate but not the opportunity cost of demand displacement. Revenue growth during promotional windows looks like success but ignores the valley that follows.
The structural blindness is that promotional accounting systems are designed to isolate the promotional period, not to measure the full economic cycle of a promotion. The spike is measured. The discount is measured. But the valley -- the period of suppressed demand following the promotion where customers who pulled forward their purchases do not buy -- is rarely connected to the promotion that caused it. NPRI would close this gap by measuring margin across the complete demand displacement window.
The Decision
We propose NPRI to answer: Did this promotion actually make us money when you account for demand pull-forward and margin given away? This metric would combine holdout-based incrementality measurement with full-cost margin accounting across the extended window, producing a single number that tells pricing teams whether a promotion created or destroyed net value.
Formula
Plain Language
Take the contribution margin from the promoted group across the full extended window (promotional period plus post-promotional valley). Subtract the contribution margin from the control group across the same window. Then subtract the total discount cost -- the per-unit discount times the number of discounted units, plus any incremental delivery or promotion execution costs. Divide the result by the control group's margin. A positive percentage means the promotion created net value. A negative percentage means it destroyed value -- you would have been better off running no promotion at all.
Notation
NPRI = (Margin_promo_extended - Margin_control_extended - Discount_cost) / Margin_control_extended x 100
Variables
| Variable | Definition | Units | Source System |
|---|---|---|---|
| Margin_promo_extended | Contribution margin from the promoted group measured across the full extended observation window (promo period + post-promo valley) | Dollars | E-commerce / Billing / Financial (Derived) |
| Margin_control_extended | Contribution margin from the holdout control group measured across the same extended window | Dollars | Experimentation Platform / Financial (Derived) |
| Discount_cost | Total cost of the discount: units sold x discount per unit, plus incremental promotion delivery costs | Dollars | Promotional Platform / Financial |
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.