Definition
The ratio of margin outcome from AI-initiated competitive price responses to the estimated margin outcome from holding price, measuring whether automated repricing creates or destroys value on a per-event and aggregate basis.
The Measurement Gap
The Gap
When a competitor drops price, most repricing platforms respond within minutes. The response generates volume. The volume shows up in revenue dashboards. Everyone celebrates. But legacy pricing metrics cannot answer the question that actually matters: did that response create more margin than it consumed?
Average selling price (ASP) tells you what you charged but not whether the price change was worth making. Gross margin percentage tells you the ratio on each unit but is blind to whether the incremental volume justified the margin compression. Win rate tells you how often you won the competitive engagement but treats a $0.02 margin win the same as a $5.00 margin win. Conversion rate moves when price drops, which looks like success -- but conversion driven by margin sacrifice is not the same as conversion driven by competitive advantage.
The structural problem is that every legacy metric measures the outcome of the price change in isolation. None of them measure the counterfactual: what would have happened if the AI had held price? Without the counterfactual comparison, there is no way to know whether the repricing AI is creating value or systematically trading margin for volume that would have arrived anyway.
The Decision
We propose CRVI to answer a specific operational question: When our repricing AI drops price in response to a competitor, does that response generate enough incremental volume to offset the margin lost? This is a per-event and aggregate evaluation that would separate value-creating competitive responses from value-destroying ones, enabling pricing teams to tune repricing rules by category, competitor, and margin threshold.
Formula
Plain Language
Take every repricing event in a given period. For each event, calculate the gross margin you actually earned after the price response. Then estimate the gross margin you would have earned if you had held price, using the trailing 14-day demand trajectory as the volume baseline. Divide actual margin by estimated hold-price margin. A result above 1.0 means the response created value. Below 1.0 means it destroyed value. Aggregate across all events for the period ratio.
Notation
CRVI = Sum(Margin_actual_after_response) / Sum(Margin_estimated_if_held)
Per-event calculation:
CRVI_event = (Price_new x Volume_new - COGS x Volume_new) / (Price_old x Volume_projected - COGS x Volume_projected)
Variables
| Variable | Definition | Units | Source System |
|---|---|---|---|
| Margin_actual_after_response | Gross margin realized in the measurement window following a competitive price response | Dollars | ERP / Financial System |
| Margin_estimated_if_held | Estimated gross margin if price had been held, using trailing demand trajectory | Dollars | Demand Forecast (Derived) |
| Price_new | The price set by the repricing AI in response to the competitive signal | Dollars per unit | Repricing Platform |
| Price_old | The price in effect before the competitive response | Dollars per unit | Repricing Platform |
| Volume_new | Actual units sold in the measurement window after the price response | Units | E-commerce / POS |
| Volume_projected | Projected units based on trailing 14-day demand, seasonality-adjusted | Units | Demand Forecast (Derived) |
| COGS | Cost of goods sold per unit | Dollars per unit | ERP / Financial System |
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.