Shutdown Quality-Duration Trade-off Index (SQDI)

GMI-MIN-025MiningIntegration-Required

Definition

Correlation between AI-optimized shutdown duration compression and post-shutdown infant mortality rate.

The Measurement Gap

Major shutdowns are the most expensive maintenance events in heavy industry, and AI scheduling tools are increasingly used to compress their duration. Every hour saved in a shutdown translates directly to production revenue recovered, creating enormous pressure to accept the optimizer's compressed timeline. Legacy shutdown management metrics reinforce this pressure. Duration variance (actual versus planned) is the headline metric, and beating the plan is celebrated. Cost metrics track whether the shutdown came in under budget. Scope completion metrics confirm whether all planned tasks were finished. What none of these metrics capture is what happens after restart. Post-shutdown infant mortality, the spike in unplanned failures that occurs when equipment returns to service after maintenance, is tracked (if at all) as a separate operational problem unrelated to shutdown execution quality. Availability metrics in the 30 days after restart are reported in isolation, without linking back to the degree of shutdown compression that preceded them. QA hold point compliance during shutdown execution is typically a binary pass/fail that does not reveal whether hold times were shortened under schedule pressure. The net result is that shutdown duration compression appears to be pure upside, because the quality cost is measured in a different reporting period by different people using different metrics.

Decision Supported: Is the AI shutdown optimizer achieving duration reduction at the expense of post-restart reliability, and what is the net economic impact after accounting for post-shutdown failure costs?

Formula

Plain Language

For each shutdown, calculate how much the AI optimizer compressed the duration compared to the engineering estimate (duration compression). Then calculate the ratio of unplanned failure rate in the first 30 days after restart to the steady-state failure rate from the 6 months before the shutdown (infant mortality ratio). Compute the correlation between duration compression and infant mortality ratio across multiple shutdowns. A positive correlation means that shutdowns with more compression tend to produce more post-restart failures.

Notation

Duration_compression = 1 - (Actual_shutdown_hours / Estimated_shutdown_hours)

Infant_mortality_ratio = Failure_rate_30day_post_restart / Failure_rate_steady_state

SQDI = Correlation(Duration_compression, Infant_mortality_ratio) across multiple shutdowns

Variables

Variable Definition Unit
Actual_shutdown_hours Realized shutdown duration from asset lockout to restart clearance Hours
Estimated_shutdown_hours Engineering estimate of shutdown duration before AI optimization was applied Hours
Duration_compression Proportion of estimated duration that was eliminated by the optimizer Ratio (0 to 1)
Failure_rate_30day_post_restart Unplanned failures in the first 30 days after restart divided by operating hours in that period Failures per operating hour
Failure_rate_steady_state Average unplanned failure rate in the 6 months preceding the shutdown Failures per operating hour
Infant_mortality_ratio Post-restart failure rate relative to steady-state baseline Ratio
SQDI Pearson or Spearman correlation coefficient between duration compression and infant mortality ratio Correlation (-1 to 1)

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Correlation (-1 to 1)
Trend Direction
Lower; approaching 0
Reporting Frequency
Per-shutdown
Category
AI-Induced Maintenance Behavior Distortion
← Schedule Buffer Consumption Index (SBCI)Drill-to-Blast Conformance Index (DBCI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment