Definition
Degree to which autonomous drill pattern execution produces the fragmentation outcomes predicted by the blast design model.
The Measurement Gap
The Measurement Gap
Autonomous drill systems report per-hole compliance metrics: collar position accuracy, depth accuracy, and angle deviation for each hole individually. These metrics typically look excellent. A system averaging 0.15m collar deviation and 0.2-degree angle deviation across all holes appears to be delivering precision drilling. Operations use these averages to justify confidence in the autonomous system's output.
The blind spot is pattern-level geometry. If every hole deviates slightly in the same direction (all shifted 0.15m north, all angled 0.2 degrees toward the wall), the per-hole metrics remain within tolerance while the blast pattern has systematically shifted from the design. The consequences include altered burden and spacing ratios, compromised wall control, inconsistent fragmentation, and potential safety concerns from blast energy distribution changes.
The problem intensifies when autonomous drill AI adapts parameters based on real-time rock sensing. Each adaptation is logged and justified at the individual hole level. But nobody aggregates the adaptations to ask whether the cumulative effect has distorted the pattern geometry. A drill that "intelligently" moved 12 consecutive holes 0.2m deeper based on rock hardness data has effectively redesigned the bottom of the pattern without blast engineering review.
Legacy metrics count trees (individual holes) while missing the forest (pattern geometry). Without aggregate conformance measurement, operations accept per-hole precision as evidence of pattern fidelity.
Decision Supported:
Is the autonomous drill delivering the blast engineer's design, or is it adapting its way into a pattern that no longer matches the intended blast geometry?
Formula
Plain Language
For every hole in the pattern, measure the deviation between where the hole was actually drilled and where it was designed to be drilled across three dimensions: collar position, depth, and angle. Combine these deviations into a single composite metric, average across all holes, and compare to the site-specific tolerance. A score of 1.0 means the pattern perfectly matches the design. A score of 0.0 means the aggregate deviation exactly equals the maximum tolerance. Negative scores indicate the tolerance has been exceeded.
Notation
DBCI = 1 - (Pattern_deviation / Pattern_tolerance)
Where:
Pattern_deviation = sqrt(Sum(Delta_position_i^2 + Delta_depth_i^2 + Delta_angle_i^2) / N_holes)
Variables
| Variable | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Delta_position_i | Absolute distance between the actual collar location and the designed collar location for hole i, measured in meters | Autonomous drill system GPS survey data |
| Delta_depth_i | Absolute difference between actual drilled depth and designed depth for hole i, measured in meters | Drill encoder depth records |
| Delta_angle_i | Absolute difference between actual drill angle and designed angle for hole i, measured in degrees (may require unit normalization) | Drill inclinometer data |
| N_holes | Total number of holes in the blast pattern | Blast design specification |
| Pattern_tolerance | Maximum acceptable aggregate deviation for the site, defined by blast engineering based on fragmentation requirements and wall control standards | Blast engineering standards (site-specific) |
| Pattern_deviation | Root-mean-square composite deviation across all holes and all three dimensions | Calculated from drill survey and design data |
Note: Delta_angle uses different units than Delta_position and Delta_depth. Normalization is required before combining. Use the site's angle-to-distance equivalence at the design depth to convert angular deviation to a linear metric, or define separate tolerance components for each dimension.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.