Definition
Proportion of underground work zones receiving ventilation based on stale or absent personnel and equipment tracking data.
The Measurement Gap
The Measurement Gap
VoD systems are typically evaluated on energy savings compared to full-volume ventilation. The headline metric is simple: how many kilowatt-hours (or dollars) did VoD save this month versus the baseline? That number looks impressive on energy reports, but it assumes the VoD system's occupancy model is accurate. If the tracking system shows a zone as occupied when it is empty, the VoD system dutifully delivers full airflow to an empty heading, and the energy savings calculation never notices the waste because it was "demand-driven."
Legacy tracking metrics focus on tag read rates and system uptime rather than occupancy accuracy. A tracking system can report 99% tag read success while systematically mislocating personnel into the wrong zones, creating phantom occupancy that the VoD system treats as real demand. Zone boundary definitions compound the problem: a tag in a lunch room physically adjacent to a production heading may register as "in-zone" due to coarse boundary definitions, triggering unnecessary ventilation.
The blind spot is the gap between what the VoD system believes and what is actually true. Without independent validation of occupancy state, the energy savings that justify VoD investment may be significantly overstated.
Decision Supported:
Is the VoD system's occupancy model accurate, and how much energy is wasted ventilating empty zones that tracking tags say are occupied?
Formula
Plain Language
Compare the VoD system's occupancy records against independent evidence of where people actually were. Every zone-hour where VoD said "occupied" but independent sources say "empty" is a phantom. Divide phantoms by total ventilated zone-hours to get the rate. Then multiply each phantom zone-hour by the airflow delivered, fan power cost, and electricity rate to calculate the dollar cost of the inaccuracy.
Notation
PZVR = Phantom_zone_hours / Total_ventilated_zone_hours
Energy cost:
Phantom_energy_cost = Sum(Airflow_phantom_zone x Fan_power_factor x Electricity_rate x Duration)
Variables
| Variable | Description | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Phantom_zone_hours | Zone-hours where VoD records show occupied status but independent validation confirms no personnel or equipment present | Cross-reference of VoD logs and independent validation |
| Total_ventilated_zone_hours | All zone-hours where VoD provided occupancy-level airflow (excludes zones at baseline/idle ventilation) | VoD control system logs |
| Airflow_phantom_zone | Actual airflow delivered to each phantom zone during phantom hours (m3/s) | SCADA airflow records |
| Fan_power_factor | Energy consumption per unit airflow (kW per m3/s), accounting for system efficiency and fan curve position | Ventilation engineering calculations |
| Electricity_rate | Cost per kilowatt-hour ($/kWh) | Utility billing records |
| Duration | Length of each phantom zone-hour interval (hours) | Calculated from VoD logs |
The energy cost calculation transforms an abstract accuracy percentage into a tangible financial figure that justifies investment in tracking system improvements or zone boundary reconfiguration.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.