Quality Hold Accuracy Rate (QHAR)

GMI-MFG-037ManufacturingPilot-Ready

Definition

Measures the percentage of automated quality holds where post-hold inspection confirmed that the held product actually contained defective units.

The Measurement Gap

Quality hold systems count holds and track release time, but nobody systematically measures whether the holds actually contained defective product. This gap creates two risks. First, if the hold threshold is too sensitive, the system generates frequent false holds that interrupt production, consume inspection resources, and erode trust without providing quality protection. Second, and more dangerously, the trust erosion from false holds degrades the response to real holds. When staff processes the fifth consecutive false hold in a week, the sixth hold (which is real) receives the same cursory review.

The decision QHAR supports is whether the hold threshold is set correctly for the balance between false alarm cost and miss cost. If QHAR is high (most holds catch real defects), the threshold is well-calibrated and the organization can trust the system. If QHAR is low (most holds are false alarms), the threshold is too tight and should be widened to reduce false alarms while monitoring the miss rate to ensure real problems are still caught. Without QHAR, the threshold is set based on engineering judgment and never validated against actual hold outcomes, which means the system's accuracy is unknown and the trust erosion from false holds is unquantified.

Formula

QHAR divides the count of hold events where post-hold inspection found defective product by the total count of hold events, expressed as a percentage.

QHAR = Holds_with_confirmed_defects / Holds_total times 100

Where Holds_with_confirmed_defects is the count of hold events where post-hold inspection found defective product in the held material. Holds_total is all automated quality hold events in the measurement period.

A QHAR of 100% means every hold caught real defects, indicating a highly accurate system that may also be under-triggering (missing some problems because the threshold is too loose). A QHAR of 0% means no holds found defects (all false alarms), indicating the threshold is far too sensitive. Higher values indicate better accuracy.

QHAR should be tracked alongside HCSR to form a complete picture of hold system effectiveness. High QHAR plus high HCSR is the ideal state where holds are accurate and the containment scope is sufficient. High QHAR plus low HCSR means holds are accurate when they fire but the lookback window is too narrow, catching the right defects but missing some affected product. Low QHAR plus high HCSR means holds over-contain but rarely catch anything, wasting inspection resources without quality benefit.

The post-hold inspection method matters for QHAR accuracy. If the inspection protocol used to evaluate held material is less rigorous than the original production inspection, it may miss defects and make QHAR appear lower than it should be. Use the most sensitive inspection method available. Define "defective" clearly as out-of-specification, not cosmetic or marginal-quality findings. Minimum sample is 10 hold events per measurement period.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Percentage
Trend Direction
Higher
Reporting Frequency
Monthly
Category
Quality Containment Effectiveness
← Hold Containment Sufficiency Rate (HCSR)Condition-Quality Model Currency Index (CQMCI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment