Post-Maintenance Quality Impact Score (PMQIS)

GMI-MFG-022ManufacturingIntegration-Required

Definition

Measures the ratio of product quality in the production window immediately following a maintenance event to steady-state product quality on the same asset.

The Measurement Gap

Maintenance and production operate in separate management systems with separate metrics. Maintenance tracks work order completion, mean time between failures, and PM compliance. Production tracks throughput, yield, and schedule adherence. Neither system measures the transition zone where they interact: the first hours of production after a maintenance event.

In practice, many maintenance events create a settling-in period. A bearing replacement may require thermal stabilization before the asset holds tolerance. An alignment adjustment may need fine-tuning under load. A calibration may need verification against production parts before the process is stable. During this settling-in period, product quality may be lower than steady-state.

The gap is that this post-maintenance quality disruption is invisible to both systems. The maintenance team sees a completed work order. The production team sees a short-term quality dip that gets averaged into the daily yield report and disappears. Nobody connects the quality dip to the specific maintenance event that caused it.

Without PMQIS, organizations cannot identify which maintenance types create post-maintenance quality disruption, how long the disruption lasts, or whether post-maintenance qualification runs are needed. They also cannot estimate the full quality cost of maintenance scheduling decisions, because the post-maintenance quality cost is hidden inside aggregate production metrics.

Formula

PMQIS is calculated as the ratio of post-maintenance quality to steady-state quality:

PMQIS = FPY_post_maintenance / FPY_steady_state

Where:

  • FPY_post_maintenance = first-pass yield during the post-maintenance production window (percentage, typically the first 4 hours of production after maintenance return-to-service, adjustable by asset type)
  • FPY_steady_state = first-pass yield on the same asset over the 30 calendar days preceding the maintenance event, excluding other post-maintenance windows (percentage)

A score of 1.0 means no quality impact from maintenance. Below 1.0 indicates quality degradation after maintenance. Above 1.0 indicates quality improvement, which is expected for some preventive maintenance types that restore capability. Track the distribution, not just the mean, because a few severe post-maintenance quality dips may be masked by an overall average near 1.0.

Key considerations: Short production runs after maintenance (fewer than 20 units) provide insufficient sample for FPY calculation. Extend the post-maintenance window or exclude from PMQIS until enough units are produced. If a product changeover coincides with maintenance, the FPY difference may be product-driven rather than maintenance-driven. Exclude these events or compare only to FPY for the same product. If the maintenance procedure specifies a run-in period, exclude run-in parts from PMQIS since those are expected quality variations. PMQIS measures unexpected quality impact after any planned run-in. Minimum sample of 20 maintenance events per asset class per measurement period.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Ratio
Trend Direction
Toward 1.0
Reporting Frequency
Monthly
Category
Maintenance-Production Decision Economics
← Maintenance Intervention Net Production Value (MINPV)Hold Containment Sufficiency Rate (HCSR) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment