Definition
Comparative equipment outcome when shore-based ROC overrides onboard assessment versus when onboard assessment is accepted.
The Measurement Gap
What This Metric Measures
SSOV measures the comparative equipment outcome when the shore-based ROC overrides the onboard chief engineer's assessment versus when the onboard assessment is accepted. It tracks 30-day equipment outcomes for every diagnostic disagreement between shore and ship, revealing whether shore-based monitoring adds genuine diagnostic value or destructively overrides experienced onboard judgment.
The Decision It Supports
When the shore-based team and the onboard team disagree about equipment condition, which assessment produces better outcomes, and under what conditions? This decision plays out dozens of times per fleet per month as ROCs equipped with AI analytics review condition data that the chief engineer has already assessed through direct observation. SSOV answers the question nobody wants to ask: is the shore team actually helping, or is centralized monitoring overriding local expertise?
Why Legacy Metrics Cannot See This
Traditional metrics track equipment failure rates and maintenance outcomes but never attribute them to the decision authority that prevailed. A turbocharger failure is recorded as a failure regardless of whether the shore team overrode the chief engineer's recommendation to inspect it or the chief engineer's own assessment missed the developing problem. Without tracking the disagreement-decision-outcome chain, the organization cannot learn which authority structure produces better results for which equipment types.
Formula
Primary Formula
SSOV = Mean_outcome_shore_prevailed - Mean_outcome_ship_prevailed
Variable Definitions
- Mean_outcome_shore_prevailed = average equipment outcome score (0-1 scale: 0 = failure within 30 days, 0.5 = degraded performance, 1.0 = normal operation) when the ROC override was followed
- Mean_outcome_ship_prevailed = average equipment outcome score when the onboard engineer's assessment was accepted
- Each disagreement event is scored by 30-day outcome
Units: Score difference, -1 to +1. Positive values mean shore overrides produce better equipment outcomes on average. Negative values mean the onboard assessment is more reliable. Values near zero mean no meaningful difference between authorities.
Edge Cases
Disagreements where neither party is clearly wrong (both recommend monitoring but with different urgency) should be classified separately as assessment-aligned but priority-divergent. Segment by satellite data quality at time of shore assessment: shore diagnoses made on stale data are a different population than those made on real-time streams. Minimum sample of 20 disagreement events per quarter is required for statistical meaning.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.