Definition
Comparative decision quality following an autonomous-to-manual control handoff versus sustained manual navigation.
The Measurement Gap
What This Metric Measures:
Comparative decision quality in the 15 minutes immediately following an autonomous-to-manual control handoff versus the same operator's decision quality during sustained manual navigation. MHDQI measures three indicators: course deviation from planned track, reaction time to new radar contacts or traffic changes, and closest point of approach to nearest vessel or navigation hazard. Each is normalized to the operator's personal baseline during sustained manual navigation.
The Decision It Supports:
Does the handoff from autonomous to manual control create a transient vulnerability window where the officer of the watch is less effective than they would be under sustained manual navigation? If the handoff degrades situational awareness, is the degradation significant enough to require structured transition protocols?
Why Legacy Metrics Cannot See This:
Near-miss rates and navigational incident statistics aggregate events over time without attributing them to specific operational transitions. A near-miss that occurs 10 minutes after an autonomous-to-manual handoff is recorded as a near-miss, not as a handoff-related event. The transient degradation in operator performance during the control transition window is invisible in aggregate safety statistics because it is diluted across all navigation hours.
Formula
Primary Formula:
MHDQI = (1/3) x [(Deviation_handoff / Deviation_baseline) + (Reaction_handoff / Reaction_baseline) + (CPA_baseline / CPA_handoff)]
Variable Definitions:
Deviation_handoff: mean course deviation from planned track in 15 minutes post-handoff. Meters.
Deviation_baseline: mean course deviation during sustained manual navigation for the same operator. Meters.
Reaction_handoff: mean reaction time to new contacts in 15 minutes post-handoff. Seconds.
Reaction_baseline: mean reaction time during sustained manual navigation. Seconds.
CPA_handoff: closest point of approach to traffic or hazards in 15 minutes post-handoff. Nautical miles.
CPA_baseline: closest point of approach during sustained manual navigation. Nautical miles.
Units:
Dimensionless ratio. 1.0 means no degradation. Above 1.0 means degradation (worse performance post-handoff). Below 1.0 means improvement.
Edge Cases:
Handoffs in low-traffic areas may not generate CPA data. Use only available indicators. Baseline establishment requires minimum 10 hours of sustained manual navigation data per operator. Segment by handoff reason (planned transition, equipment fault, edge case). Minimum sample: 20 handoff events per measurement period.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.