Definition
Net economic outcome of ML-forecast-driven lay-up and reactivation decisions including total transition costs.
The Measurement Gap
What This Metric Measures:
Net economic outcome of ML-forecast-driven lay-up and reactivation decisions, accounting for total lay-up costs, reactivation costs, revenue foregone during lay-up, and revenue earned or losses avoided by trading during the period the model recommended lay-up. LDNV answers the complete economic question: was the full lay-up-reactivation cycle cheaper than continuing to trade at prevailing market rates?
The Decision It Supports:
Was laying up the vessel at the time the model recommended more or less expensive than continuing to trade at a loss, and was the reactivation timed correctly? The lay-up decision is binary and consequential: the vessel either trades or it does not. The ML model that recommends lay-up is betting that the market will be bad enough and long enough that the full cost of the lay-up cycle (preparation, maintenance, reactivation) is less than the losses from continuing to trade.
Why Legacy Metrics Cannot See This:
Fleet utilization rates and lay-up duration statistics report that vessels were laid up. They do not measure whether the lay-up decision was economically correct. A fleet that laid up three vessels for six months shows 75% utilization. Whether that 75% was the right number depends entirely on whether the lay-up cycle cost less than trading at prevailing rates would have cost, a counterfactual analysis that utilization metrics do not perform.
Formula
Primary Formula:
LDNV = Revenue_counterfactual_trading - (Layup_cost + Reactivation_cost + Revenue_foregone_during_layup)
Variable Definitions:
Revenue_counterfactual_trading: estimated revenue from continuing to trade at actual market rates during the lay-up period. Dollars.
Layup_cost: crew repatriation, dehumidification, port or anchorage fees, and class maintenance during lay-up. Dollars.
Reactivation_cost: crew mobilization, recommissioning, class re-survey, and port costs. Dollars.
Revenue_foregone_during_layup: any charter or spot revenue that would have been earned during the lay-up period. Dollars.
Units:
Dollars per lay-up cycle. Positive means lay-up was economically correct because trading would have lost more than the lay-up cycle cost. Negative means lay-up destroyed value because trading would have been cheaper than the total lay-up-reactivation cycle.
Edge Cases:
Market rates moved during the lay-up period. Use actual rates, not forecast rates, for the counterfactual. Vessel condition degradation during extended lay-up should include incremental maintenance costs at reactivation that would not have been needed if the vessel had stayed trading. Minimum sample: each lay-up decision is individually assessed because these are major capital allocation decisions.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.