Route Optimization Net Economic Value (RONEV)

GMI-MAR-008Maritime IndustriesIntegration-Required

Definition

Net economic impact of AI-recommended voyage routing versus the counterfactual route.

The Measurement Gap

What This Metric Measures:
Net economic impact of following AI-recommended voyage routing versus the counterfactual (the master's intended route, standard weather routing, or previous-voyage pattern), accounting for fuel savings, schedule impacts, demurrage and dispatch, port congestion costs, and opportunity costs. RONEV captures total economic value, not just the fuel savings that voyage optimization vendors typically report.

The Decision It Supports:

Is the voyage optimization algorithm producing net-positive economic outcomes when all downstream costs and savings are aggregated, or is it saving fuel while destroying value elsewhere? An optimizer that reduces fuel consumption by 3% but causes the vessel to miss a berth window, incurring two days of demurrage, has destroyed value: even though the fuel savings dashboard shows a positive result.

Why Legacy Metrics Cannot See This:

Voyage optimization platforms report fuel savings against a baseline. Fleet managers see fuel cost reduction and assume value creation. But the baseline comparison ignores schedule impacts, port costs, demurrage risk, and opportunity costs that the routing decision created. A voyage that saves $15,000 in fuel but costs $40,000 in demurrage because the optimized route arrived outside the berth window shows a positive fuel metric and a negative total economic outcome. Legacy reporting isolates the fuel dimension from the commercial consequences: RONEV integrates them.

Formula

Primary Formula:

RONEV_voyage = (Cost_counterfactual - Cost_AI_route) - Implementation_cost

RONEV_fleet = (1/N) x SUM(RONEV_voyage_i)

Variable Definitions:

Cost_AI_route: total voyage cost when AI route was followed, including fuel, port charges, demurrage, waiting time cost, and any weather-related delays. Dollars.

Cost_counterfactual: estimated total voyage cost for the alternative route (master's plan, standard routing, historical pattern). Dollars.

Implementation_cost: any cost of following the AI route that would not exist otherwise, such as additional waypoints requiring watch adjustments. Dollars.

N: number of voyages in the measurement period.

Units:

Dollars per voyage (RONEV_voyage) and average dollars per voyage (RONEV_fleet). Positive means AI routing added value. Negative means AI routing destroyed value.

Edge Cases:

Counterfactual estimation is inherently uncertain. Use the best available comparator such as the master's filed route plan before optimization or the standard route for that trade. Weather that changed after the routing decision should be attributed based on decision-time information, not hindsight. Voyages where the master overrode the AI should be excluded from RONEV but included in a separate Override Value metric. Minimum sample: 20 completed voyages per quarter.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Currency
Trend Direction
Higher; increasing
Reporting Frequency
Per voyage
Category
Voyage and Fleet Commercial Decision Quality
← Lay-Up Decision Net Value (LDNV)Voyage Optimizer Confidence Calibration (VOCC) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment