Definition
Estimated dollar amount of overpayment (and underpayment) in straight-through-processed claims, measured by sampling STP claims and comparing the auto-adjudicated payment against expert human re-evaluation.
The Measurement Gap
Claims STP automates the payment decision for low-complexity claims, prioritizing speed and efficiency. The assumption is that correctly classified claims will be correctly valued. But classification accuracy and valuation accuracy are different capabilities. An STP system can correctly identify a claim as a "minor water damage, single room, no structural" and still overpay by 15% because it missed a deductible application, misinterpreted a policy endorsement, overlooked a subrogation opportunity, or defaulted to replacement cost when actual cash value applied. The overpayment accumulates invisibly because no one reviews the claim after payment. Legacy metrics cannot detect this. Loss ratio captures aggregate severity but cannot distinguish STP leakage from legitimately higher claim costs. Claims frequency measures volume, not valuation accuracy. Time to settlement measures how fast claims close, and STP excels at speed, but speed and accuracy are independent dimensions. First contact resolution tracks whether claims are handled in one interaction, not whether the payment was correct. Severity trends measure average claim cost over time but cannot isolate STP valuation error from genuine cost inflation.
Decision Supported:
Is claims STP creating leakage that erodes loss ratio improvement gains, and if so, which claim types and which valuation dimensions are the primary leakage drivers?
Formula
Plain language: Sample claims that were auto-paid via STP. Have an experienced adjuster re-evaluate each sampled claim blind to the STP payment amount. Compare the expert valuation to the STP payment. The difference, aggregated across the sample and projected to the full STP population, is the leakage estimate.
Notation:
SVLR = (1/N) x Sum of (Payment_STP_i - Valuation_expert_i) / Valuation_expert_i x 100
Leakage_projected = SVLR x Total_STP_payments
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Payment_STP_i | Amount paid by the auto-adjudication system for sampled claim i | Dollars |
| Valuation_expert_i | Expert adjuster's independent valuation of the same claim i | Dollars |
| N | Number of sampled STP claims | Count |
| Total_STP_payments | Total dollar amount paid through STP in the measurement period | Dollars |
| Leakage_projected | Estimated total overpayment (or underpayment) across all STP claims | Dollars |
Positive SVLR indicates systematic overpayment (leakage). Negative SVLR indicates systematic underpayment (customer harm and regulatory risk).
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.