Pricing Disparate Impact Index (PDII)

GMI-INS-002InsuranceInfrastructure-Dependent

Definition

Measures the degree to which AI-driven pricing produces systematically different premium outcomes across demographic groups after controlling for actuarially justified risk factors, revealing proxy discrimination that alternative data features may introduce.

The Measurement Gap

AI pricing models incorporate alternative data features (credit-based scores, consumer behavior, social media signals, IoT data) that may correlate with protected class membership through geographic, economic, or behavioral proxies. A model can produce actuarially sound aggregate results while systematically overcharging or undercharging specific demographic groups. Legacy metrics cannot detect this. Loss ratio measures aggregate profitability, not whether that profitability is evenly distributed across demographic segments. Combined ratio captures expense and loss efficiency without any fairness dimension. Complaint ratio tracks explicit dissatisfaction but misses policyholders who never complain because they do not know they are being overcharged relative to their risk. Retention rate measures who stays and who leaves, but cannot distinguish actuarially justified attrition from price-driven disparate impact. Rate filing approval confirms compliance with filed factors, not whether the model's output pattern produces disparate outcomes through unfiled proxy effects. None of these metrics operate in the dimension of cross-group outcome comparison after controlling for legitimate risk factors.

Decision Supported:

Are the alternative data features in the pricing model producing outcomes that would fail a disparate impact analysis under state insurance regulatory standards, and if so, which features are the primary drivers of the disparity?

Formula

Plain language: For each protected class proxy group (defined by census tract demographics, since individual protected class data is not collected), compare the average model-predicted premium to the average actuarially expected premium based on traditional rating factors only. The gap, if it varies systematically by demographic proxy, is the disparate impact signal.

Notation:

PDII_g = (P_model_g - P_actuarial_g) / P_actuarial_g

PDII = max|PDII_g| across all demographic proxy groups g

Variables:

Variable Definition Unit
P_model_g Average AI-model-predicted premium for policies in demographic proxy group g Dollars
P_actuarial_g Average premium using only traditional actuarially justified rating factors for the same policies Dollars
g Demographic proxy group (defined by census tract income quintile, racial/ethnic composition quartile, or similar geographic proxy) Classification

Report both the maximum absolute PDII across groups and the group-specific values. Positive PDII_g indicates group g pays more under the AI model than traditional factors would predict.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Percentage
Trend Direction
Lower; approaching 0
Reporting Frequency
Quarterly
Category
AI Underwriting and Pricing Integrity
← Portfolio Concentration Risk Index (PCRI)Telematics Score Calibration Index (TSCI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment