Comfort-Energy Trade-off Index (CETI)

GMI-FAC-006Facilities ManagementIntegration-Required

Definition

Ratio of energy savings achieved by AI BMS optimization to the comfort quality degradation those savings created, measuring whether the AI is finding genuine efficiency or simply trading occupant comfort for energy metrics.

The Measurement Gap

The AI BMS optimizes HVAC for energy efficiency. It learns that reducing cooling by 2 degrees during afternoon hours saves 8% on HVAC energy. The setpoint drift is small enough that no individual complaint triggers investigation, but aggregate comfort satisfaction declines over three months. EUI improves on the energy dashboard. Tenant satisfaction drops on the occupant dashboard. Nobody connects the two because they are measured by different teams on different timelines. The AI is optimizing one metric at the expense of another, and no metric measures the trade-off. Energy benchmarks measure consumption. Comfort surveys measure satisfaction. Nothing measures the exchange rate between them: how much comfort was sacrificed for how much energy savings.

Decision Supported:

When the BMS reports energy savings from AI optimization, how much comfort did the building sacrifice to get there, and is the trade-off acceptable for the building's tenant profile?

Formula

Plain language: Calculate the energy cost savings the AI achieved compared to baseline (weather-normalized). Calculate the comfort quality degradation that occurred during the same period using a composite of temperature deviations, humidity excursions, IAQ measurements, and complaint rate changes. Express as a ratio: dollars saved per comfort-quality point lost.

Notation:

CETI = ΔEnergy_cost_saved / ΔComfort_score_lost

Variables:

Variable Definition Unit
ΔEnergy_cost_saved Reduction in energy cost attributable to AI BMS optimization (current vs. baseline, weather-normalized) $
ΔComfort_score_lost Degradation in comfort quality score: composite of temperature deviations from setpoint, comfort complaint rate change, humidity excursions, IAQ deviations Composite index

Note: If comfort improves AND energy saves (both metrics improve), CETI is technically negative. This is the best outcome. Track separately as win-win optimization.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Currency
Trend Direction
Higher; more energy savings per unit of comfort degradation = better trade-off
Reporting Frequency
Quarterly
Category
Building Automation Trust and Comfort Economics
← BMS Override Erosion Rate (BOER)Capital Impact Ranking Delta (CIRD) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment