Degradation Comfort Tax (DCT)

GMI-FAC-002Facilities ManagementIntegration-Required

Definition

Excess energy consumed and comfort quality lost due to building system degradation that has not crossed a failure threshold: the hidden cost of running degraded-but-operational equipment.

The Measurement Gap

Building systems degrade continuously between maintenance events. A chiller losing 18% efficiency consumes significantly more energy and delivers marginally less cooling, but it has not tripped an alarm and is not predicted to fail soon. PM Compliance counts schedule adherence. MTTR counts repair speed. EUI measures total energy per square foot. None of them isolate the energy waste and comfort erosion attributable to sub-failure-threshold degradation. Occupants experience gradual comfort drift (hot spots, humidity excursions) that appears in satisfaction surveys months later with no link to the system degradation that caused it. The cost of degraded-but-operational equipment is real, ongoing, and invisible to every standard facilities metric.

Decision Supported:

How much is the building's degraded-but-operational equipment costing in energy waste and comfort erosion that no alarm, work order, or PM compliance metric can see?

Formula

Plain language: For each monitored building system, compare current energy consumption and output quality (discharge air temperature, cooling capacity, heating efficiency) against the system's baseline performance when newly installed or last commissioned. The gap (energy consumed above baseline for the same output, plus comfort deviation from design conditions) is the degradation comfort tax.

Notation:

DCT = Σ [(Energy_current_s − Energy_baseline_s) × Cost_per_kWh + Comfort_deviation_s × Cost_per_comfort_unit]

Variables:

Variable Definition Unit
Energy_current_s Current energy consumption of system s for a standard load profile kWh
Energy_baseline_s Energy consumption of system s at the same load profile when newly installed or last commissioned kWh
Cost_per_kWh Blended energy rate $/kWh
Comfort_deviation_s Deviation of system s output from design conditions (degrees off setpoint, CFM below design, lumens below spec) Composite
Cost_per_comfort_unit Estimated cost of comfort deviation (occupant productivity impact, complaint handling, portable unit rental) $/unit

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Currency per period
Trend Direction
Lower; lower tax = less hidden degradation cost
Reporting Frequency
Monthly
Category
Predictive FM Maintenance Economics
← Intervention Timeliness Index (ITI)Facilities Alert Economic Yield (FAEY) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment