Definition
Ratio of maintenance cost per mile to billing revenue per mile for each DOT-regulated motor pool vehicle, measuring whether the billing model funds the maintenance the vehicle's utilization demands.
The Measurement Gap
No metric measures the correlation between motor pool billing rate, dispatch frequency, and maintenance investment per mile for DOT-regulated vehicles. Motor pool operations bill departments a per-mile or per-day rate, but that rate was typically set when the vehicle was new and rarely adjusts as the vehicle ages and maintenance costs escalate. The billing model and the maintenance reality diverge silently, and no metric watches the gap.
Three legacy metrics are blind to this funding mismatch:
-
Motor pool revenue/cost ratio evaluates overall profitability of the motor pool operation but is blind at the vehicle level. A fleet-wide ratio can look healthy while individual high-utilization vehicles are being dispatched at rates far below their actual maintenance cost per mile. Low-rate dispatches on aging vehicles look profitable in aggregate because newer vehicles subsidize them.
-
Fleet maintenance cost per vehicle reports an average that hides vehicle-level variance. A fleet averaging $0.12/mile in maintenance may contain vehicles at $0.05/mile and vehicles at $0.35/mile: the aggregate metric cannot distinguish between a well-funded vehicle and one whose billing rate has not kept pace with its maintenance demands.
-
Vehicle availability shows the vehicle is available for dispatch and therefore appears healthy. But availability says nothing about whether the funding model supports the maintenance required to keep it available. A vehicle can be available today precisely because deferred maintenance has not yet caused a breakdown: availability is a lagging indicator that arrives too late.
Decision Supported:
Is the motor pool billing rate for each DOT-regulated vehicle generating sufficient revenue per mile to fund the maintenance that vehicle's utilization pattern actually demands?
Formula
Plain Language
MPMFR divides what it costs to maintain a vehicle per mile by what the motor pool charges per mile for that vehicle. If the ratio is below 1.0, billing covers maintenance. If it exceeds 1.0, the vehicle costs more to maintain per mile than it generates in billing revenue: the funding model is underwater for that asset.
Notation
$$MPMFR = \frac{MaintenanceCostPerMile}{BillingRevenuePerMile}$$
Where:
$$MaintenanceCostPerMile = \frac{TotalMaintenanceCost_{period}}{TotalMiles_{period}}$$
$$BillingRevenuePerMile = \frac{TotalMotorPoolBilling_{period}}{TotalMiles_{period}}$$
Variables
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| TotalMaintenanceCost | Sum of all maintenance work order costs (labor, parts, external services) on the asset in the reporting period | Currency |
| TotalMotorPoolBilling | Sum of all motor pool billing charges collected for the asset in the reporting period | Currency |
| TotalMiles | Total miles driven by the asset in the reporting period, sourced from odometer readings or telematics | Miles |
| MaintenanceCostPerMile | Maintenance cost normalized by utilization | Currency/Mile |
| BillingRevenuePerMile | Billing revenue normalized by utilization | Currency/Mile |
| MPMFR | The ratio itself: dimensionless, where < 1.0 means billing covers cost | Ratio |
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.