Guaranteed Minimum Erosion Index (GMEI)

GMI-TEL-024TelecommunicationsIntegration-Required

Definition

Frequency with which per-slice guaranteed resource delivery falls into the bottom 10% of the tolerance band simultaneously across multiple slices during contention periods, measuring whether "compliance" is masking systematic under-delivery.

The Measurement Gap

Measurement Gap and Decision

Decision Supported: Is the resource broker genuinely meeting guarantees, or is it gaming the tolerance band by delivering the minimum acceptable level across all slices simultaneously?

Measurement Gap:

Every multi-tenant SLA monitoring system reports a binary result: compliant or non-compliant. A slice receiving resources at 95.1% of its guarantee in a system with ±5% tolerance is "compliant": technically indistinguishable from a slice receiving 100% of its guarantee. When the resource broker pushes every slice to the bottom of its tolerance band simultaneously during contention, the SLA dashboard shows 100% compliance while every enterprise customer experiences degraded-but-technically-acceptable service. No current monitoring system measures the distribution of delivery within the tolerance band, and no system detects whether floor-delivery is happening across slices simultaneously: the signature of a broker optimizing for compliance rather than quality. GMEI closes this gap by measuring how often the broker parks multiple slices at their guarantee floor during contention, revealing whether "compliance" is genuine delivery or systematic gaming.

Citations:

  • ETSI GR NFV-REL 007, "NFV Resiliency Requirements," 2024: defines tolerance bands for virtual network function performance but does not measure delivery distribution within those bands.
  • MEF 61.1, "Service OAM Performance Monitoring Implementation Agreement," 2023: specifies SLA performance thresholds without addressing the within-tolerance delivery quality problem.

Formula

Plain Language: During contention periods, for each measurement interval, check how many active slices are receiving resources within the bottom 10% of their guaranteed tolerance band. If the number is disproportionately high (more than expected by chance), the broker is systematically eroding guarantees.

Notation:

GMEI = (Intervals_with_simultaneous_floor_delivery / Total_contention_intervals) × 100

Where simultaneous_floor_delivery = intervals where ≥50% of active slices are in the bottom 10% of their guarantee tolerance band simultaneously.

Variable Definitions:

  • Guarantee_delivered_i,t = actual resource delivery to slice i during contention interval t (resource units)
  • Guarantee_committed_i = committed guaranteed minimum for slice i (resource units)
  • Tolerance_band_i = acceptable range around guarantee (e.g., ±5%)
  • Floor_zone = bottom 10% of tolerance band (for a ±5% band: guarantee_committed × 0.95 to guarantee_committed × 0.955)
  • Contention intervals = intervals where total demand across all slices exceeds available pool capacity

Units: Percentage of contention intervals showing simultaneous floor delivery. 0% = guarantees are met at their committed levels during contention. High GMEI = the system is systematically sitting at the floor.

Sign Convention:

Lower is better. High GMEI indicates the resource broker is gaming tolerance bands.

Edge Cases:

  • Different slices may have different tolerance bands: normalize to percentile position within each slice's own band.
  • Very brief contention periods (less than 1 minute): aggregate to minimum 5-minute intervals to avoid noise.
  • Few active slices (fewer than 5): the "50% simultaneous" threshold needs adjustment. Use absolute count (3 or more slices at floor).
  • Minimum sample: 100 contention intervals per measurement period.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Percentage
Trend Direction
Lower
Reporting Frequency
Monthly
Category
Inter-Slice Resource Equity and Cascade Risk
← Cross-Slice Degradation Proportionality Score (CSDP)Resource Borrowing Cascade Depth (RBCD) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment