Technician Skill Breadth Index (TSBI)

GMI-TEL-017TelecommunicationsPilot-ReadyPattern O-9: Skill Atrophy

Definition

Change in the breadth of job types successfully completed per technician over time, measuring whether AI dispatch specialization is narrowing the workforce's capability range.

The Measurement Gap

Measurement Gap and Decision

What TSBI Measures: TSBI tracks the change in the breadth of job types successfully completed per technician over time. It reveals whether workforce optimization is narrowing technician skill portfolios by over-specializing work assignments.

Decision Supported:

Is the workforce optimizer building efficient specialists at the cost of resilient generalists, and is the complex-job completion penalty growing as a result? Without TSBI, workforce management reports efficiency gains (more jobs per shift, lower drive time) without examining whether those gains come at the cost of a de-skilled workforce that cannot handle multi-domain jobs.

Why This Is Unmeasured:

Workforce optimization systems measure efficiency: jobs completed per shift, average drive time, first-time-fix rate. None of these capture whether individual technicians are maintaining the skill breadth needed for complex, multi-domain assignments. The optimizer's objective function rewards specialization (assigning each technician the job type they're fastest at) which produces measurable efficiency gains while silently eroding the workforce's ability to handle anything outside their narrowing specialty. When a complex job arrives that requires fiber, power, and RF work on the same tower, the specialist who has been assigned only fiber work for six months cannot complete it. The efficiency metric never captures this cost because it only measures what was assigned, not what was lost (MIT Sloan Management Review, "The Hidden Cost of Workforce AI Optimization," 2024; TM Forum, "Field Force Transformation: Automation vs. Resilience," 2023).

Formula

Plain Language: For each technician, count the number of distinct job type categories they have successfully completed in the trailing 6 months. Compare to their historical breadth from the same trailing window one year ago (or the baseline period). Average across the entire technician population.

Notation:

TSBI = (1/T) × Σ [Job_types_current_i / Job_types_baseline_i]

Variable Definitions:

  • Job_types_current_i = distinct job type categories successfully completed by technician i in the current trailing 6-month window (count, dimensionless)
  • Job_types_baseline_i = distinct job type categories for the same technician in the baseline trailing 6-month window, typically one year prior or the first 6 months post-optimizer deployment (count, dimensionless)
  • T = number of technicians in the measurement population (count, dimensionless)

Units:

Dimensionless ratio. 1.0 = no change in breadth. Less than 1.0 = narrowing (atrophy). Greater than 1.0 = broadening (improvement).

Sign Convention:

Higher is better. TSBI below 1.0 means the average technician is handling fewer job types than they did during the baseline period.

Edge Cases:

  • Technicians hired after the baseline period: use their first 6 months of employment as the baseline window.
  • Job type taxonomy must be consistent across the baseline and current periods. If categories were reorganized, normalize before comparison.
  • Technicians who transferred roles or markets: exclude from the measurement population to avoid confounding organizational changes with optimizer-driven specialization.
  • Track the distribution, not just the average: the mean may look acceptable while 20% of technicians have been reduced to single-skill assignments. Minimum sample: 50 technicians per market.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Ratio
Trend Direction
Higher; At or above 1.0
Reporting Frequency
Semi-annually
Category
Fraud, Workforce, and Regulatory Calibration
← Fraud Threshold Optimization Score (FTOS)Cross-Slice Degradation Proportionality Score (CSDP) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment