Curtailment Allocation Equity Index (CAEI)

GMI-RE-009Renewable EnergyPilot-Ready

Definition

Coefficient of variation of curtailment rate across portfolio assets. A low value means curtailment burden is shared; a rising value means the optimizer is concentrating curtailment on the same assets, with revenue and warranty consequences the portfolio total conceals.

The Measurement Gap

When a grid operator orders curtailment across a renewable portfolio, someone (or something) decides which assets reduce output and by how much. In most modern portfolios, this decision is made by a fleet optimization algorithm that allocates curtailment to minimize total portfolio revenue loss. The optimizer's logic is rational: curtail the assets with the lowest marginal revenue first. The problem is that rational portfolio-level optimization can produce systematic asset-level inequity that distorts individual asset financial performance and potentially breaches asset-level contractual obligations.

The measurement gap is that portfolio operators track total curtailment volume and total revenue impact, but do not measure how that burden is distributed across individual assets. An asset near a congestion point on the transmission network might consistently receive 60% of the portfolio's curtailment while representing only 15% of its capacity. That asset's financial performance looks poor relative to plan, its PPA compliance metrics degrade, and its investors see returns below expectations, all because the optimization algorithm consistently sacrifices it to protect higher-revenue assets elsewhere in the portfolio.

Without CAEI, this pattern is invisible at the portfolio level because total curtailment management looks efficient. The inequity only surfaces when someone investigates why a specific asset is underperforming, which may take quarters to trigger.

The decision CAEI supports is whether the curtailment optimizer is distributing revenue loss fairly across the portfolio or whether specific assets are being systematically sacrificed, distorting their financial performance and potentially breaching asset-level PPA obligations that assume more equitable curtailment exposure.

Formula

For each asset in the portfolio, calculate its curtailment rate (curtailed energy divided by potential energy). Then compute the coefficient of variation across all assets. A low coefficient means the curtailment burden is equitably distributed. A high coefficient means some assets bear a disproportionate share.

Formula (Notation):

CAEI = standard_deviation(CR_1, CR_2, ..., CR_n) / mean(CR_1, CR_2, ..., CR_n)

Where: CR_j = Curtailed_Energy_j / Potential_Energy_j, for each asset j

Variable Definitions:

Variable Definition
CR_j curtailment rate for asset j (dimensionless ratio)
Curtailed_Energy_j energy curtailed at asset j during the measurement period, in MWh
Potential_Energy_j energy that asset j would have produced absent curtailment, in MWh
n number of assets in the portfolio

Edge Cases and Measurement Boundaries:

Assets with different interconnection agreements may have structurally different curtailment obligations. Normalize by subtracting each asset's contractual minimum curtailment before computing CAEI to avoid flagging legitimate structural differences as inequity. CAEI is undefined for single-asset portfolios since this is inherently a multi-asset metric. For assets added or removed during the measurement period, compute CAEI only for assets present for the entire period to avoid distortion from partial data.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Coefficient of variation
Trend Direction
Lower; more equitable
Reporting Frequency
Quarterly
Category
Autonomous Dispatch and Storage Economics
← Compliance Margin Index (CMGI)Derate Compounding Exposure Index (DCEI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment