Definition
Percentage of promotional fare bookings that displaced a full-fare booking the passenger would have made anyway, versus the percentage that represent genuinely incremental ridership.
The Measurement Gap
When a railroad runs promotional fares, it tracks promotional bookings as a volume number. Revenue reports show total revenue including promotional fares. But no legacy metric distinguishes between promotional bookings that brought new riders into the system and promotional bookings where existing customers simply gamed the system to get a lower price they would have paid full fare for. Ridership growth on promoted routes may appear healthy while net revenue declines because the "new" riders are actually existing customers who shifted from full-fare to promotional. Booking volumes look strong, but they mask revenue dilution. The failure mode is a promotional strategy that reports incremental volume while actually subsidizing existing demand: the railroad pays the discount but gets no new customers. This is invisible because no legacy metric compares individual passenger booking behavior before and after promotional availability to determine whether each promotional booking was genuinely incremental.
Decision Supported:
Are promotional fares generating new riders, or are existing customers gaming the system to get a lower price they would have paid full price for?
Formula
Plain language: For each promotional fare booking, assess whether the passenger would have traveled at the full fare. Evidence of cannibalization: same passenger, same route, booking pattern shifted from full-fare to promotional after promotions launched; no net ridership increase on promoted routes despite promotional volume.
Notation:
PFCR = Cannibalized_bookings / Total_promotional_bookings
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Cannibalized_bookings | Promotional bookings where the same passenger previously booked the same route at full fare, or where aggregate ridership on the route did not increase despite promotional volume | Bookings |
| Total_promotional_bookings | All bookings at promotional fares in the measurement period | Bookings |
A value of 0% means all promotional bookings are incremental (ideal). 100% means all promotional bookings cannibalized full-fare (waste). Track separately for each promotional campaign.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.