Definition
Net economic value of AI-directed speed profile changes across the network, computed as fuel cost savings minus the crew cost, asset utilization cost, and delay penalty costs those speed changes create.
The Measurement Gap
Network optimizers slow trains to smooth flow and save fuel. Fuel consumption per gross ton-mile captures the fuel savings but structurally cannot see the costs those speed reductions create elsewhere. When the optimizer slows a train, the crew may hit Hours of Service limits, triggering an unplanned crew change that costs more than the fuel saved. The asset (locomotive and cars) turns fewer miles per day, reducing revenue-generating capacity. Customers with transit-time commitments may incur delay penalties. OTP captures schedule adherence but cannot net the schedule cost against the fuel saving because it does not operate in the economic dimension. Crew utilization measures labor efficiency but cannot attribute crew overtime or unplanned crew changes to specific optimizer decisions. The failure mode is a system that reports fuel savings as a success while the total cost (crew, asset, penalty) exceeds the savings. The network optimizer appears to create value while actually destroying it, because no single legacy metric nets the cross-domain costs against the single-domain savings.
Decision Supported:
When the network optimizer slows trains to smooth flow, is the railroad saving money or losing it? Should the optimizer's speed-reduction authority be constrained?
Formula
Plain language: Sum the fuel saved by every speed reduction the optimizer directed. Then sum the costs those speed reductions created: additional crew hours, reduced asset utilization, and customer delay penalties. Subtract costs from savings.
Notation:
NSONV = Σ Fuel_savings_i − Σ (Crew_cost_i + Asset_cost_i + Penalty_cost_i)
Variables:
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel_savings_i | Fuel cost avoided by speed reduction on segment i: (fuel_at_planned_speed − fuel_at_actual_speed) × fuel_price | Dollars |
| Crew_cost_i | Incremental crew cost from extended trip time: additional HOS-triggered crew changes, overtime, deadhead to reposition relief crews | Dollars |
| Asset_cost_i | Opportunity cost of reduced asset velocity: car-hours and locomotive-hours consumed by the speed reduction × marginal revenue per hour | Dollars |
| Penalty_cost_i | Customer delay penalties triggered by late arrival attributable to the speed reduction | Dollars |
Positive NSONV = net value created. Negative = speed optimization destroyed value. Report both aggregate and per-decision.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.