Seismic Interpretation Independence Score (SIIS)

GMI-OG-019Oil and GasInfrastructure-Dependent

Definition

Seismic Interpretation Independence Score, or SIIS, is the degree to which AI seismic interpretation produces findings that are geologically independent from the human interpreter''s preliminary model, measured by the divergence between AI-identified features and the pre-existing geological framework the interpreter brought to the workflow. The KPI exists to answer one decision: is the AI adding independent geoscientific value to prospect evaluation, or is it reinforcing the interpreter''s prior beliefs and inflating prospect confidence without adding information?

The Measurement Gap

Cyrus is a senior geophysicist on the subsurface team at an independent operator working an extensive but mature carbonate play. The team uses an AI seismic interpretation platform that ingests reprocessed 3D volumes, applies trained feature detectors for faults, channels, karst features, and direct hydrocarbon indicators, and produces a candidate feature set the interpreters work from. The platform was acquired two years ago, partly to speed prospect generation and partly to reduce the inter-interpreter variability the team had been struggling with. The early results were promising: interpretation cycle times shortened, and the team felt the AI was catching subtleties on noisy lines that human eyes were missing.

Eighteen months in, Cyrus started noticing a pattern in the prospect inventory. The prospects the team was generating with the AI had a structural and stratigraphic vocabulary that was strikingly similar to the prospects in the operator''s established producing area. The fault geometries the AI flagged matched the team''s existing fault model in style and orientation. The stratigraphic features the AI extended matched the operator''s play model''s expected facies distribution. The team was happy with the consistency. Cyrus, who had been doing exploration interpretation for thirty years and had a particular instinct for when an interpretation is too clean, was less happy. The AI was producing prospects that fit the existing geological framework. It was not producing prospects that challenged the framework.

The test came when the team applied the AI to a different sub-basin where the operator had recently picked up a leasehold position. Cyrus prepared his preliminary structural and stratigraphic model in the usual way (paper section work, well log correlation, regional tie-ins) and saved it as a snapshot before he loaded the AI workflow. The AI ran on the new volume. Its candidate features came back. Cyrus walked through them. Almost every AI-flagged feature was either a confirmation of a feature he had already drawn or an extension of one, a fault he had drawn that the AI carried further down section, a channel he had identified that the AI traced further laterally. Almost none of the AI features were structurally or stratigraphically independent of his prior interpretation. The AI''s output, in his sub-basin, in his project, on his volume, was largely a higher-resolution version of his own work.

When Cyrus discussed this with the AI vendor''s technical contact, he learned the platform''s training data was heavily weighted toward the operator''s own historical interpretations in their established areas. The team had been the platform''s primary fine-tuning source. The model had learned the team''s interpretive style, which is precisely what the team had asked it to do during configuration. The unintended consequence was that the model''s outputs in new areas tended to look like the team''s outputs in old areas, regardless of the geological reality. The AI was a sophisticated mirror.

Legacy interpretation metrics do not catch this. Interpreter productivity is up. Feature density is up. Inter-interpreter variability is down. The team''s prospect inventory is growing. None of these metrics report whether the AI is providing independent geological information or whether it is confidently restating the team''s priors back to them with higher resolution.

What is missing is a metric that asks whether the AI is adding information the interpreter did not have before the AI ran.

Formula

Seismic Interpretation Independence Score, or SIIS, is the degree to which AI seismic interpretation produces findings that are geologically independent from the human interpreter''s preliminary model, measured by the divergence between AI-identified features and the pre-existing geological framework the interpreter brought to the workflow. The KPI exists to answer one decision: is the AI adding independent geoscientific value to prospect evaluation, or is it reinforcing the interpreter''s prior beliefs and inflating prospect confidence without adding information?

The structural form is a categorization-and-counting exercise. For each interpretation session on a defined volume, capture two things at the start: the AI''s candidate feature set on the raw volume, and the interpreter''s preliminary structural and stratigraphic model produced before or independently of the AI''s output. For each AI-identified feature, a geoscientist scores it into one of three categories. Confirming features align with the prior model: same fault, same channel, same stratigraphic surface. Extending features add new detail within the prior model''s framework, a fault the interpreter drew, carried by the AI into a deeper interval where the interpreter had not extended it yet. Diverging features contradict the prior model or identify features that are absent from it, a fault orientation the interpreter did not draw, a stratigraphic feature inconsistent with the play model''s expected facies. SIIS is the ratio of extending and diverging features to total features.

The methodological core of the metric is the pre-session model snapshot. The interpreter''s preliminary model has to be captured before the AI''s output is examined, or the SIIS scoring becomes circular: the interpreter has seen the AI''s output and will inevitably recall their own preliminary thoughts as more aligned with the AI than they really were. The snapshot is a discipline. It takes additional interpreter time and it produces an artifact that did not exist before, but without it the metric measures nothing useful.

The edge cases the metric has to handle. The first is greenfield exploration where the interpreter genuinely has no prior model. SIIS in that case is undefined: there is no bias to measure against because there is no prior. Greenfield work should be excluded from SIIS calculation and handled by a different assurance practice, typically a peer-review process on the AI''s output and the resulting prospects. The second is divergent findings that turn out to be artifacts: acquisition footprint, processing noise, multiple energy, an isolated reflection that the AI interpreted as a fault. These are not real independent geological findings and should be excluded from the SIIS numerator after QC. The third edge case is the perfect score trap. A SIIS that approaches 1.0 sustained over many sessions is not a sign of an unusually independent AI; it is a sign that the AI''s output may be uncoupled from the underlying geology, which is a different kind of failure mode. The metric tracks toward a healthy middle, not toward extremes.

The other consideration is the time trend. As interpreters become familiar with the AI tool, they may learn the AI''s typical output patterns and start producing preliminary models that anticipate what the AI will say. A declining SIIS over a year of usage is a sign of this anchoring: the team is learning to interpret like the AI does, which makes the AI''s outputs feel confirmatory because the human work has converged on the AI''s style. Operators noticing this trend should implement blind interpretation protocols on a sample of sessions: the AI interprets the volume before the human shares any preliminary model, and the comparison is done against that blind baseline.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Category
Subsurface Decision Quality
← Proxy Model Fidelity Decay Rate (PMFDR)

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment