Shut-In Restart Cost Index (SIRCI)

GMI-OG-012Oil and GasIntegration-Required

Definition

Shut-In Restart Cost Index, or SIRCI, is the ratio of the total cost to return a well to pre-shut-in production levels to the lifting cost savings the shut-in achieved during the idle period.

The Measurement Gap

Aisha is the production economics analyst at a Bakken operator running about three hundred wells across the McKenzie and Williams County acreage. When WTI dropped through forty-five dollars in March, her company''s AI production optimizer recommended shutting in twenty-eight marginal wells whose lifting cost had moved above the realized netback. The economic case in the optimizer''s output was tidy: each well was burning twelve to forty dollars per barrel in lifting cost against a netback that had gone negative, so the math said stop. The operations VP authorized the shut-ins. The optimizer''s recommendation was implemented across two weeks.

Eight weeks later, when prices recovered enough to justify restart, the cost ledger of bringing those twenty-eight wells back told a different story than the economics had assumed. The first nine wells came back fine, a swab job, a fluid pump, an artificial-lift restart, and they hit their pre-shut-in rates within ten days. The next eleven wells had problems. Three needed scale milling because the well sat long enough for paraffin and asphaltene to deposit in the production tubing. Four came back with crossflow between zones that had not been there before the shut-in, requiring zonal isolation work. Two restored to rates fifteen to twenty percent below pre-shut-in stabilized production and never recovered. The last eight wells were the worst. Two of them developed water coning during the shut-in that nobody could reverse; one had a casing leak appear at restart that traced to thermal cycling of an already-compromised cement bond; one had a downhole pump that had been sitting in cold mud for eight weeks and broke a shaft on the first pull cycle.

When Aisha totaled the restart costs against the lifting cost savings the shut-ins had achieved during the idle period, the program had saved $1.4 million in lifting cost and spent $3.2 million in remediation, lost production during ramp, and rate shortfall over the first ninety days post-restart. The AI''s economic model had been honest within its frame (lifting cost minus netback) and the recommendation it produced was internally consistent. The frame was the problem. The model had no representation of what shutting a well in physically did to the well. It treated shut-in as a free pause and restart as a free unpause, and the wells did not.

Legacy production economics metrics do not catch this. Lifting cost per barrel is computed on producing wells. Operating expense reports include workover spending but report it as the cost of the workover, not as the cost of the prior shut-in decision that triggered the workover. The standard well economic model the AI inherits its frame from is a steady-state model that does not include shut-in penalty terms. The cost is real; it just lives in a different cost center than the savings, and nobody runs the subtraction.

What is missing is a metric that asks the question the AI''s economic model is not equipped to ask: when the AI recommends a shut-in, what does the well actually cost to restart, and is the saving worth the penalty?

Formula

Shut-In Restart Cost Index, or SIRCI, is the ratio of the total cost to return a well to pre-shut-in production levels to the lifting cost savings the shut-in achieved during the idle period. The KPI exists to answer one decision: when the AI economic model recommends shutting in a well, does the recommendation account for what restart will physically cost the operator, or is the model trading visible savings for hidden penalty?

The total cost in the numerator has three components. The first is the intervention cost: workover, stimulation, chemical treatment, downhole pump work, or any other physical remediation needed to put the well back in producing service. The second is the production revenue foregone during the ramp from restart to stabilized rate, calculated as the lost barrels priced at the realized price during the ramp period. The third is the rate shortfall: the difference between pre-shut-in stabilized rate and post-restart stabilized rate, multiplied by price, integrated over the first ninety days after restart. The ninety-day window captures the bulk of the reservoir-driven and well-driven rate deficits that show up only after the well has been on production long enough to stabilize again.

The denominator is the lifting cost saved during the idle period. This is the simplest number in the calculation and it is the number the AI''s economic model already produces when it generates the shut-in recommendation. The honest version of the shut-in decision is the denominator minus the numerator. SIRCI expresses the relationship as a ratio so that comparisons across wells with different scales are meaningful.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Category
Production & Commercial Economics Distortion
← Hedging Strategy Correlation Exposure (HSCX)Constraint-Proximity Equipment Life Index (CPELI) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment