Definition
Ratio of on-time completion rate for NRC-required surveillances and safety-related preventive maintenance to the on-time completion rate for all scheduled maintenance, measuring whether AI scheduling optimization deprioritizes regulatory work when resources are constrained.
The Measurement Gap
AI-driven work scheduling optimizers in nuclear plants balance competing demands across hundreds of maintenance and surveillance tasks. When resources are constrained, the optimizer must make trade-offs. The concern is whether NRC-required Technical Specification surveillances and safety-related preventive maintenance receive appropriate priority or whether the optimizer treats them as interchangeable with production-oriented tasks. Schedule compliance measures overall on-time completion across all work types. PM completion rate tracks whether PMs get done. Neither metric segregates regulatory work from discretionary work in the completion statistics. The invisible failure mode is that the AI optimizer, when pressed for resources, systematically defers the regulatory work (which has flexible windows and grace periods) in favor of production-affecting tasks (which have immediate operational consequences), and the aggregate schedule compliance number stays green while the regulatory work completion rate quietly drops below the overall average.
Decision Supported
Is the AI work scheduling system treating Tech-Spec-required surveillances and safety-related maintenance with appropriate priority, or is it deferring regulatory work to optimize production-related task completion?
Formula
Plain language: Calculate the on-time completion rate for regulatory/safety-related work orders. Calculate the on-time completion rate for all work orders. Divide. If the ratio is 1.0, regulatory work completes at the same rate as everything else. If it's below 1.0, regulatory work is being deprioritized.
Notation:
SSSSI = OTR_regulatory / OTR_overall
Variables:
- OTR_regulatory = on-time completion rate for Tech Spec surveillances + safety-related PMs + Maintenance Rule (a)(1) activities (dimensionless, 0 to 1)
- OTR_overall = on-time completion rate for all scheduled work orders in the same period (dimensionless, 0 to 1)
- On-time = completed within the scheduled window or Tech Spec frequency requirement, whichever is more restrictive
Sign convention: SSSSI = 1.0 means parity. Values below 1.0 mean regulatory work is deprioritized (bad). Values above 1.0 mean regulatory work is prioritized above average (expected and appropriate in nuclear).
Aggregation period: Monthly rolling.
Edge Cases
- Tech Spec surveillance frequencies have different periodicities (daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly, refueling): normalize to "completed within allowed window" rather than raw timeliness
- Grace periods (Tech Spec SR 3.0 allows 25% frequency extension): count work completed within the grace period as on-time for regulatory compliance purposes, but flag as "grace period used" for SSSSI trending. Chronic grace period use is a leading indicator of scheduling pressure
- Outage periods: compute SSSSI separately for online and outage periods. Outage scheduling dynamics are fundamentally different from online operations
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.