Definition
The ratio of probability-weighted dollar impact of losing the top-N consolidated vendors to the realized dollar savings from that consolidation, surfacing whether AI-driven vendor consolidation creates hidden concentration risk that exceeds the optimization benefit.
The Measurement Gap
Legacy MRO supply chain metrics reward consolidation without measuring the fragility it creates. Spend under management rewards fewer vendors as a percentage of spend. Procurement savings rewards the year-one win. Vendor on-time delivery measures the vendors still active, not the structural exposure created by removing the others. No standard metric surfaces the trade-off: how much of the realized savings is structurally at risk because of the concentration the consolidation produced. When a category review consolidates bearings spend from 14 vendors to 3, the $2.4M projected savings looks defensible: until two of the three consolidated vendors share a parent company that faces regulatory action, and the operation loses access to two-thirds of its supply base in a single event. The realized cost of the consolidation (expedites, stockouts, emergency requalification) can exceed the savings by multiples. The decision VCFI supports: whether to continue consolidation, hold current concentration, or actively re-fragment the supplier base, and which categories require dual-source mandates regardless of AI cost recommendation.
Formula
VCFI = Σ_n P(disruption_n) × impact_$n / realized_consolidation_savings$
Variables:
- n = index of top-N consolidated vendors in scope (typical: top 3, top 5, or top 10 by spend share)
- P(disruption_n) = annual probability of meaningful disruption from vendor risk scoring or external risk data
- impact_$_n = production-impact dollars if vendor n is down for stated recovery period (from supply chain twin simulation or historical-event empirics)
- realized_consolidation_savings_$ = year-over-year procurement savings attributable to the consolidation decision
Worked example: Bearings consolidation from 14 to 3 vendors, $2.4M realized annual savings. Disruption probabilities: vendor A 8%, vendor B 12%, vendor C 6%. Impact estimates from twin simulation: A loss = $4.6M, B = $5.2M, C = $3.1M. Probability-weighted fragility: (0.08 × $4.6M) + (0.12 × $5.2M) + (0.06 × $3.1M) = $1.18M. VCFI = $1.18M / $2.4M = 0.49. Also compute at P95 disruption probability. If P95 VCFI exceeds 1, consolidation is net-negative on a tail-weighted basis.
Edge cases: Multi-vendor ownership concentration must be detected. Parent-company linkage often defeats apparent diversification. Geographic concentration matters independently. For rare disruption probabilities, use Bayesian methods to combine historical empirics with external risk data.
Data sources: Vendor disruption probability from risk-scoring platform. Production impact from supply chain twin or historical empirics. Realized savings from procurement savings tracking. Vendor ownership and geographic data from vendor master augmented with parent-company linkage.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.