Procurement Override Value Index (OVI-MROSC)

GMI-MROSC-005MRO Supply ChainIntegration-RequiredPattern O-5: Override Value / Trust

Definition

The measured outcome quality of human overrides on AI-recommended vendor selection, safety stock, expediting, and substitution decisions, separated from outcome quality of the AI recommendations themselves.

The Measurement Gap

The reorder agent recommends Vendor A for a $42,000 PO based on lead time, price, and risk score. Your senior buyer overrides to Vendor B. The override happens silently: no required reason code, no comparison view, no follow-up. Six months later, Vendor B's delivery is two weeks late and the resulting stockout costs $180,000 in expedited freight and overtime. Two weeks after that, the same buyer overrides another AI recommendation, this time correctly: Vendor C goes bankrupt and the override to Vendor D avoids a six-month disruption. Nobody knows which overrides are good and which are bad. Buyer productivity measures POs issued, not override decisions made. Vendor on-time delivery measures the vendor, not the buyer's choice of vendor. PO cycle time measures process speed, not decision quality. Even the AI platform itself usually measures override frequency, which it treats as a problem to be reduced, not as a decision quality signal to be analyzed. A high override rate could mean the AI is bad and humans are saving you, or it could mean humans are emotionally attached to legacy vendors and degrading outcomes. Without measurement, you cannot tell which. If overrides are systematically better than AI, you should retrain. If worse, tighten governance. If equal, the analytical labor of overriding is wasted.

Decision Supported:

Whether to tighten override governance, whether to retrain the AI on patterns where overrides consistently outperform, and which buyer or planner overrides reflect institutional knowledge worth capturing versus habit worth correcting.

Formula

Plain language: When a human overrides the AI, did the human's choice produce a better, equal, or worse outcome? Score each override, weight by decision dollar value, and compute a value-weighted ratio of override benefit to total override exposure.

Notation:

POVI = Sum( I(outcome_override > outcome_predicted_AI) * decision_weight_i ) / Sum( decision_weight_i )

Where i indexes each override event.

Variables:

Variable Definition Unit
I(.) Indicator function: 1 if override outcome better, 0 if equal, -1 if worse (ternary scoring) Ternary
outcome_override Realized outcome of the human's chosen action $ or days
outcome_predicted_AI Predicted outcome of the AI's recommendation (counterfactual) $ or days
decision_weight_i Dollar value of decision i $

Denominator note: The denominator is the sum of decision weights, not the count of override events. This ensures a single high-value override that fails catastrophically is not diluted by twenty low-value overrides that succeed trivially. POVI > 0.5 means overrides are improving outcomes on a dollar-weighted basis; POVI < 0.5 means the organization is paying for the privilege of degrading its own procurement.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Unit
Ratio
Trend Direction
Diagnostic; Increasing (if > 0.5) or diagnostic
Reporting Frequency
Quarterly (with 90-day outcome horizon)
Category
B - Alert, Recommendation & Override Quality
← Supply Network Twin Fidelity (SNTF)Reorder Alert Net Economic Yield (RANEY) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment