Definition
The net value per guardrail intervention: the estimated harm exposure contained in correctly blocked requests minus the value of legitimate work wrongly blocked or degraded by rewrites.
The Measurement Gap
There is no metric that tells you the value of legitimate work blocked or rewritten by guardrails, which means tuning ratchets tighter with the collateral cost invisible.
Formula
GNPY = (sum(blocked_harm_c) - sum(blocked_value_w)) / interventions_sampled
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.
At a Glance
Decision Supported
Whether guardrail thresholds should tighten or loosen, replacing the incident-driven one-way ratchet with a priced trade.