Definition
Proportionality between exclusion zone size and the risk event that triggered it, measuring whether safety zone responses are calibrated or systematically over-conservative.
The Measurement Gap
Autonomous haul systems are designed with conservative safety boundaries. When personnel or unauthorized vehicles enter an exclusion zone, the AHS stops all affected trucks and holds them until the zone is cleared and manually re-authorized. This conservatism is intentional and appropriate as a design principle. However, it creates a measurement problem: traditional safety metrics track exclusion events as binary safety incidents, counting total stops and total downtime. Physical Availability treats these stops the same as any other unplanned downtime. Utilization metrics absorb them as lost production hours.
None of these metrics distinguish between a stop that prevented a genuine collision and a stop triggered by a boundary that was larger than the actual risk required. A light vehicle entering a zone boundary 200 meters from the nearest truck triggers the same stop as a light vehicle entering 30 meters from a truck at full speed. Legacy metrics like Lost Time Injury Rate, Total Recordable Injury Frequency, and equipment utilization cannot quantify whether the safety system's conservatism is proportionate. Without proportionality measurement, operations face a false binary: accept all production losses as the cost of safety, or pressure to reduce safety boundaries without evidence.
Decision Supported:
Are AHS exclusion zone boundaries appropriately sized, or are they causing avoidable production losses that erode the AHS business case without improving safety?
Formula
Plain Language: For every AHS exclusion zone stop event, classify whether genuine proximity risk existed (a person or vehicle was within the stopping envelope of a moving truck) or whether the stop was triggered by a boundary incursion where no truck was at risk. EZPS is the proportion of stops that were genuinely necessary. A companion metric translates avoidable stops into production cost by multiplying their count by the average restart delay, the fleet throughput rate, and the marginal revenue per ton.
Notation:
EZPS = Necessary_stops / Total_exclusion_stops
Production_cost = Avoidable_stops x Avg_restart_delay x Fleet_TPH_rate x Revenue_per_ton
| Variable | Definition | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| Necessary_stops | Exclusion events where genuine proximity risk existed (personnel within the stopping envelope of a moving truck) | Count |
| Total_exclusion_stops | All AHS exclusion stop events during measurement period | Count |
| Avoidable_stops | Total_exclusion_stops minus Necessary_stops | Count |
| Avg_restart_delay | Average time from exclusion stop to full truck resumption | Minutes (3 to 8 minutes typical) |
| Fleet_TPH_rate | Fleet tons per hour at time of stop | Tons per hour |
| Revenue_per_ton | Marginal revenue per ton of ore | Currency per ton |
An EZPS of 1.0 means every stop was necessary. An EZPS of 0.5 means half the stops were avoidable.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.