Definition
Incidence rate of safety indicators occurring within 72 hours of a CII-driven speed reduction.
The Measurement Gap
What This Metric Measures
CSRT measures the incidence rate of safety-related indicators occurring within 72 hours of a CII-driven speed reduction decision. Safety indicators include crew fatigue reports, MLC rest-hour threshold approaches, weather-exposure incidents from compressed schedules, and compressed port turnaround exceptions. The metric quantifies how frequently CII optimization transfers unreported risk to crew safety or schedule margins.
The Decision It Supports
Is CII optimization transferring unreported risk to crew safety, weather exposure, or schedule compression, and if so, how frequently? A CII-driven speed reduction saves fuel and improves the vessel's carbon intensity rating. But the slower voyage means the vessel arrives later, which may compress port turnaround time, push the crew closer to rest-hour limits during catch-up operations, or force the vessel to transit through a weather window that a faster passage would have stayed ahead of.
Why Legacy Metrics Cannot See This
Legacy safety metrics (LTIFR, near-miss rate, fatigue reports) are tracked independently of commercial and environmental decisions. When a crew member files a fatigue report 48 hours after a CII-driven speed reduction compressed the port call from 36 hours to 18 hours, the fatigue report goes into the safety management system. The speed reduction decision stays in the voyage optimization system. No metric links the two. CSRT connects CII decisions to their downstream safety consequences by checking every speed reduction event for safety indicators within a 72-hour window, creating visibility into a risk transfer that would otherwise remain invisible across separate reporting systems.
Formula
Primary Formula
CSRT = Speed_reductions_with_safety_indicators / Total_CII_speed_reductions
Variable Definitions
- Speed_reductions_with_safety_indicators = CII-driven speed reduction events followed by at least one safety indicator within 72 hours (count)
- Total_CII_speed_reductions = all CII-driven speed reduction events in the measurement period (count)
- Safety indicators include: rest-hour near-violations (within 1 hour of MLC limit), weather window compression, port turnaround below standard minimum, crew fatigue report filed
Units: Percentage. 0% means no safety indicators are associated with CII speed reductions. Higher percentages indicate more frequent risk transfer from emissions optimization to crew safety domains.
Edge Cases
Correlation versus causation is a critical consideration, not every safety indicator after a speed reduction is caused by it. CSRT is a flag for investigation, not proof of causation. Segment by operating conditions because speed reductions in low-traffic, good-weather conditions are less likely to create safety indicators than reductions on tight-schedule, winter North Atlantic voyages. Minimum sample of 20 CII-driven speed reduction events per quarter is needed for meaningful CSRT computation.
Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.