DER Dispatch Tolerance Index (DDTI)

GMI-EU-037Energy & UtilitiesIntegration-Required

Definition

Measures the correlation between specific DERMS dispatch patterns (time of day, duration, frequency, cumulative monthly dispatches) and customer opt-out/complaint rates, identifying which patterns are tolerable vs. which drive attrition.

The Measurement Gap

Traditional demand response program management tracks aggregate participation rates and seasonal MW delivery. When participation declines, program managers investigate through surveys and focus groups: qualitative research that identifies general dissatisfaction but rarely connects attrition to specific dispatch characteristics with statistical confidence. Meanwhile, the DERMS optimizer continues running dispatch patterns that are driving opt-outs, because there is no metric quantifying the attrition cost of specific dispatch decisions.

The specific failure point is optimizer invisibility to behavioral consequences. The DERMS optimizer maximizes grid service value subject to technical constraints: battery SoC limits, ramp rates, service obligations. It has no behavioral constraint quantifying that evening dispatches between 5 and 9 PM at high discharge depth cause opt-out rates three times higher than daytime dispatches. Without that constraint, the optimizer continues maximizing revenue using dispatch patterns the program cannot sustain.

DDTI enables the specific operational decision of which dispatch patterns should become hard constraints in the DERMS optimizer: inviolable rules that override revenue optimization when they trigger attrition above a tolerable threshold. A DDTI value of 3.0 for consecutive-day dispatch means that pattern triples opt-out rates and should be prohibited regardless of revenue potential.

Without DDTI, program managers observe rising attrition and implement broad retention interventions (higher incentives, reduced event frequency across all participants) losing the targeting precision needed to preserve high-revenue dispatch patterns while eliminating only the attrition-driving ones.

DERMS device-level dispatch logging combined with CIS opt-out and complaint records enables the statistical correlation analysis that connects specific dispatch patterns to specific attrition outcomes at scale.

Formula

DDTI(p) = OptOut_rate(exposed_to_pattern_p) / OptOut_rate(not_exposed_to_pattern_p)

Variables:

  • p: dispatch pattern category. Defined patterns include: evening dispatch (5–9 PM local time), long-duration dispatch (greater than 2 hours), high-frequency dispatch (more than 3 events per week), deep discharge (greater than 80% depth of discharge), consecutive-day dispatch (dispatch on two or more sequential days)
  • OptOut_rate(exposed): percentage of customers who experienced pattern p within the measurement period who opted out of the program or filed a complaint about dispatch within 30 days of the exposure (%). Source: DERMS dispatch records cross-referenced against CIS opt-out and complaint records by customer ID
  • OptOut_rate(not_exposed): same calculation for customers enrolled during the same period who did not experience pattern p. Serves as the control group

Calculation Frequency: Monthly, computed over rolling 6-month windows to accumulate sufficient opt-out events per pattern category
Output: Ratio per pattern. DDTI(p) of 1.0 = the pattern has no detectable effect on attrition. Above 1.5 = the pattern increases attrition by 50% or more: monitor closely. Above 2.5 = the pattern more than doubles attrition rate: consider a hard DERMS constraint. Above 3.0 = add a hard constraint preventing that pattern even if it reduces dispatch revenue. Track DDTI by season: summer and winter tolerance may differ significantly by device type.

Proposed formula, pending validation pilots.

At a Glance

Category
Energy Economics and DER Fleet Management

Decision Supported

Which dispatch patterns should the DERMS avoid or limit to maintain customer participation, and where is the tolerance boundary?

← DER Dispatch Lifecycle Externalization Rate (DDLER)DER Value Stack Sequencing Efficiency (DVSSE) →

Assess Your Organization

The AI-GPS Assessment evaluates your AI governance maturity and recommends KPIs like this one for your implementation roadmap.

Take the Free AI-GPS Assessment